Wed
Oct 14, 1998 - 5:20PM EDT - BUSY NIGHT: DC VIGIL, ABC NEWS, 20/20,
NIGHTLINE
(Original Source: www.wiredstrategies.com)
DC VIGIL
Tonight at 7PM, there will be a vigil for Matthew Shepard at the west side
of the US Capitol building in Washington, DC. The event is hosted by HRC,
GLAAD and NGLTF. Special guests will include Ellen Degeneres, Ellen's mom
Betty, and Anne Heche. As can dles are not allowed on the Capitol grounds,
attendees are urged to bring glow sticks and other lighted objects - in
addition, there should be some additional glow sticks available. Check
back here later this evening for coverage of the DC vigil and, if the
digital camera works, pictures online.
ABC NEWS
ABC's World News Tonight will likely be airing a story about hate crimes
and the intolerant atmosphere on American college campuses. The show is
expected to be aired this evening.
20/20
ABC's 20/20 is reported to be broadcasting this evening an interview with
the girlfriend of one of Matthew's accused killers, Kristen Price.
NIGHTLINE
Nightline is possibly doing a portion of its broadcast on the Matthew
Shepard case as well.
Note from John of Wired
Strategies:
As I will be attending the vigil, this site will next be updated in a few
hours.
Wed Oct 14, 1998 - 2:20PM EDT - "FAMILY VALUES" GROUP SAYS
HATE CRIME LAWS "SILENCE POLITICAL OPPOSITION"
The Family Research Council, a "pro-family" religious right
organization based in Washington, DC - and one of several organizations
that announced a new "ex-gay" ad campaign within hours of
Matthew being found near-dead along a country rode in Wyoming - told the
New York Times yesterday that:
"'Hate crimes laws have
nothing to do with perpetrators of violent crime and everything to do with
silencing political opposition,' said Steven Schwalm, an analyst with the
Family Research Council, a Washington group dedicated to defendin g faith,
family and freedom. 'It would criminalize pro-family beliefs,' Schwalm
said....'This basically sends a message that you can't disagree with the
political message of homosexual activists.'" - From the New York
Times, October 13, 1998, "Gay Stude nt Who Was Kidnapped and Beaten
Dies".
[FYI - Schwalm worked before for Oliver North, and is a former Republican
Senate staffer.]
A few questions from John of
Wired Strategies:
1) When Matthew's attackers tied him spread-eagle to a fence, and in
response to his pleas to spare his life, broke his head open with the butt
of a pistol and left him to die, what particular theory of "political
opposition" were they espousing? And why wouldn't we want to silence
political opposition that manifests itself in the savage murder or
America's youth?
2) Is this article suggesting that pistol-whipping and murder are
"pro-family beliefs"?
3) I guess kidnapping and murdering someone because they're gay definitely
qualifies as a "political message." But does anyone really have
a problem sending a "message that you can't disagree" with the
summary execution of a 21-year-old college kid?
4) An overwhelming majority of Americans oppose Matthew's murder and would
like to see it not happen again. Are they all "homosexual
activists"? Or is the use of that term simply a convenient way to
further demonize Matthew's sympathizers?
CONTACT INFO: The Family Research
Council has disconnected their main email account, but they say on their
Web site that: "If you have a message or request of a time-dated or
urgent nature, we ask that you call our order line at 800-225-4 008."
Wed Oct 14, 1998 - 10:10AM EDT
- FRANK RICH (NYT) SLAMS MILITANT FUNDAMENTALISTS
Frank Rich: The Road to Laramie
NEW YORK TIMES, October 14, 1998
JOURNAL / By FRANK RICH
On the same day Americans learned last week that Matthew Shepard, a
5-foot-2, 105-pound gay college student, had been tortured, strung up like
an animal and left to die on a fence outside Laramie, Wyo., the Family
Research Council was co-hosting a pre ss conference in Washington. It was
the latest salvo in a six-month campaign by the religious right, with the
tacit, even explicit, approval of Republican leaders, to demonize gay
people for political gain in this election year.
This particular press conference
was to announce a new barrage of ads -- a TV follow-up to a summer print
campaign -- in which alleged former homosexuals who have
"changed" implore others to do likewise "through the power
of Jesus Christ." The commerci als, gooey in style, end with a
slogan: "It's not about hate -- It's about hope."
But it's really about stirring up
the fear that produces hate. If these ads were truly aimed at gay people,
they wouldn't be broadcast at extravagant cost to the wide general
audience reached by TV, and they wouldn't be trumpeted in Washington,
insurin g free national exposure, three weeks before Election Day. The ads
themselves, despite the sugar-coating of "hope," ooze malice. In
one of them, homosexuality is linked to drug addiction and certain death
by AIDS; all of them implicitly posit that homosex uality is itself a
disease in need of a cure.
Matthew Shepard has now been
"cured," that's for sure. As his uncle, R.W. Eaton, told The
Denver Post, the 21-year-old Matt, who aspired to a career in diplomacy
and human rights, was "a small person with a big heart, mind and soul
that someone tried t o beat out of him." Of his nephew's shattered
body Eaton said, "It's like something you might see in war." And
a war it is. Go to the Family Research Council's Web site and you will
find a proud description of its readiness to "wage the war against
the ho mosexual agenda and fight to maintain the traditional meaning of
'family.'"
The head of the Family Research
Council is Gary Bauer, a G.O.P. power broker and putative Presidential
candidate, who disingenuously goes on talk shows to say that his
organization hates no one and deplores violence. But if you wage a
well-financed med ia air war in which people with an innate difference in
sexual orientation are ceaselessly branded as sinful and diseased and
un-American seekers of "special rights," ground war will follow.
It's a story as old as history. Once any group is successfully s
capegoated as a subhuman threat to "normal" values by a
propaganda machine, emboldened thugs take over.
Two weeks after James Byrd was
savagely dragged to his death from a pickup truck in Texas in June, I
wrote a column about an ugly incident outside the G.O.P. state convention
in Fort Worth, where a mob threatened a group of gay Log Cabin Republicans
wh o were protesting discriminatory treatment by their own party. The
gay-bashers had been directly preceded by steady saber-rattling from
Republican politicians: Senator James Inhofe of Oklahoma had likened James
Hormel, a gay nominee to an ambassadorship, to David Duke; Pat Robertson
had wondered on TV if God might wreak havoc on Disney World for its
"Gay Days"; the Texas G.O.P. spokesman had likened Log Cabin to
the Ku Klux Klan.
Just two days after this
near-brush with violence in Fort Worth, Trent Lott was on TV seconding the
religious right's condemnation of gay people as sinful and sick. A
frightened gay Texas Republican who had been at the convention melee asked
when I int erviewed him then: "Do you have to have someone hurt and
beat up and dragged from a truck to stop this?"
Months later not even the murder
in Laramie has moved Senator Lott to apologize for his words, and still no
major G.O.P. leader dares take on its "religious" wing and its
crusade against people like Matthew Shepard.
In one of the new ads in that
supposedly hate-free crusade, an ostensibly loving mother condemns her son
for the "bad choice" of being gay. Is it that mother who speaks
for American values, or is it Matthew's? "Go home, give your kids a
hug," Judy Shep ard said in a message read by a tearful hospital
spokesman who announced her child's death early Monday morning, "and
don't let a day go by without telling them you love them."
New York Times email address -
tell them Frank Rich is right on: letters@nytimes.com
Wed Oct 14, 1998 - 9:45AM EDT - LOG CABIN CALLS FOR DEATH PENALTY
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE CONTACT: Kevin Ivers
October 13, 1998 (202) 347-5306 X12
LOG CABIN CALLS FOR DEATH
PENALTY FOR MURDERERS OF MATTHEW SHEPARD
"Brutality of this Kind is Intolerable, Indefensible and Deserving of
the Most Severe Punishment," says Gay GOP Group
(WASHINGTON) The nation's largest
gay Republican organization condemned the brutal murder of Matthew
Shepard, a 21 year-old gay student in Laramie, Wyoming, and called on
prosecutors to seek the death penalty under current Wyoming law for the
suspects who have been charged with the crime.
"This was an
incomprehensible act of brutality against an innocent and defenseless
person," said Richard Tafel, executive director of Log Cabin
Republicans. "From the evidence, it is clear that anti-gay hatred was
a factor in this crime, but the sheer savagery of the murder of Matthew
Shepard is of such a magnitude that there should be no question but to
seek the most severe punishment available under the laws of Wyoming -- the
death penalty. Society must send the strongest message that brutality of
this kind is intolerable, indefensible and deserving of the most severe
punishment."
Tafel praised Governor Jim
Geringer (R-WY) for his swift and outspoken condemnation of the crime, and
for sending the message that while the state legislature should work to
address the problem of hate crimes in Wyoming, there is also a b igger
societal problem that must be addressed immediately by the citizens of the
state.
"Governor Geringer is
correct in focusing the immediate response on what this horrifying act
says about the condition of our society in general," Tafel said,
"and the need for all of us to reflect on how such a thing could
happen. While Matthew Shepard's killers must be brought to justice, and
legislation could be a short-term goal, we must tackle the larger issue of
hatred and violence in our society immediately. We should, as a nation,
ask ourselves why this happened, and what each of us can do from
preventing it from ever happening again."
Log Cabin Republicans is the
nation's largest gay Republican organization, with 50+ chapters
nationwide, a full-time Washington office and a federal political action
committee.
#####
Log Cabin Republicans Kevin Ivers
(202) 347-5306 phone Director of Public Affairs
(202) 347-5224 fax
http://www.lcr.org
Wed Oct 14, 1998 - 12:10AM EDT
- NATIONAL AND LOCAL VIGILS GROW
There are a growing number of national and local vigils being planned to
honor the memory of Matthew Shepard, and to demand that Congress and the
states pass hate crimes legislation. Information on the Washington, DC
vigil, taking place on Wednesday October 14, follows.
What: National Vigil in
Washington, DC
Date: Wednesday 10/14/98
Time: 7:00 PM
Location: West Steps of the U.S. Capitol Building
Public Transportation:
* Metro: Orange & Blue Lines to the Capitol South Station; or the Red
Line to Union Station.
* Metrobus: 32,34,36 Lines to the US Capitol.
Attending: Member of Congress,
Ellen DeGeneres & Anne Heche, Betty DeGeneres and other Community
Leaders.
For additional information: HRC
202-628-4160 http://www.hrc.org NGLTF 202-332-6483 http://www.ngltf.org
GLAAD 202-986-1360 http://www.glaad.org
Tue Oct 13, 1998 - 7:40PM EDT
- WORDS HAVE CONSEQUENCES
Consider the following:
1) "'Homosexuals are condemned from the pulpit, in the classroom, at
the dinner table, in the halls of Congress, and in that atmosphere it's
not surprising that a certain percentage of people emerge feeling like
it's all right to physically attack gays an d lesbians,' says Mark Potok,
spokesman for the Southern Poverty Law Center, which monitors hate crimes.
'I think mainstream leaders, religious and political, have to bear some
responsibility for these types of crimes.'" USA Today, October 13,
1998
2) "'The law should deal
with facts and acts and not attitudes,'' says Steven Schwalm, senior
analyst with the Family Research Council, which opposes hate crime
legislation. ''We have great sorrow and regret that the incident occurred.
Bu t to try and blame pro-family or religious Americans because they
oppose homosexual activity is Orwellian.'" USA Today, October 13,
1998
3) According to a June 12, 1998
story in the Orlando Sentinel, police arrested a young man this past June
who ripped down dozens of gay-pride rainbow flags flying in downtown
Orlando - the flags were approved by the City Council in a 6-1 vote.
Family members say the man, 19-year-old Brendan Shawn McGarity, became
angry about the flags after he heard televangelist Pat Robertson warn
earlier this week that Orlando would be punished by God for allowing the
gay pride banners to fly. The fla gs had been mounted on city light posts
in observance of National Gay Pride Month. McGarity's 15-year-old sister,
Lindsay McGarity, said her brother thought the city's decision to allow
the flags "was a mockery of God. That's what he said. It was sort of
his excuse for doing it.'' She said her brother had seen Robertson's
televised warning that Orlando risks the wrath of God in the form of
hurricanes, earthquakes, terrorist bombs and possibly a meteor by letting
the flags fly on city poles. Robertson's warning was aired on The 700 Club
television show on the Christian Broadcasting Network.
The point here: words have
consequences. If some college kid could be spurred to commit a crime by
the practically laughable claim that the flying of rainbow flags will lead
God to send hurricanes, earthquakes and meteors, imagine what k ind of
crimes impressionable college-aged kids could be inspired to commit when
repeatedly told by political, religious, and "pro-family"
leaders that gay people are not just sick, immoral, and scorned by God,
but have actually chosen to be that way.
Tue Oct 13, 1998 - 6:22PM EDT
- VISIT REV. FRED PHELP'S WEB SITE
While extremely offensive, I recommend everyone visit the home
page of Reverend Fred Phelps, the preacher from the Westboro
Baptist Church in Kansas who, along with his extended family, has m ade a
career out of picketing funerals of gay people, people with AIDS,
suspected gay sympathizers and others. They usually appear with small
children, all holding outrageous signs reading "God Hates Fags"
and "AIDS Cures Fags," among others. If that wa sn't enough, the
Web address of the site is www.godhatesfags.com, which should give you a
sense of where he's coming from. Phelps has announced that he will be
picketing Matthew's funeral on Friday in Casper, Wyoming.
With regards to Matthew's
funeral, Phelps says on his Web site: "It's too late to rescue
Matthew Shepard from the life of sin into which he was lured by the
perverted, depraved and decadent American society into which he was born.
All wh o say 'it's OK to be gay,' have the blood of Matthew & millions
more on their hands."
I again warn that Phelps' site is
extremely offensive. But as the national media is now covering the fact
that his church will be picketing the funeral, I think it important that
we all "know our enemy." In addition, I suggest you click here
and take a look at the photo
archives on his site. Then sit down and have a hard drink.
Feel free to send Phelps an email
message at webmaster@godhatesfags.com.
Tue Oct 13, 1998 - 5:05PM EDT
- ACTIVISTS PROPOSE WEB BLACKOUT DAY
Date: Tue, 13 Oct 1998 12:16:02 -0700
From: "Martin W., Webcreate.Com"
We are launching a small campaign
on the web for web sites to go dark on Oct 16 with an active link to Hate
Crimes Prevention Act on HRC. The info is located on http://gayplace.com.
Please help us propagate. This could bring a lot more attention to this
important piece of legislation.
"Martin Wiesiolek -
GayPlace.com
Note from John Aravosis of Wired Strategies: Friday the 16th is the day of
Matthew's funeral.
Tue Oct 13, 1998 - 3:45PM EDT
- ANTI-GAY PREACHER TO PICKET SHEPARD FUNERAL
I just received this feedback from a friend in Wyoming:
In today's Casper Star Tribune details of Matt's funeral here in Casper
were announced. The funeral will be held 1:30 PM, Friday at St. Mark's
Episcopal Church. The paper had several good, local editorials and letters
to the editor from around the count ry about Matt's death. Also several
articles about how many Wyomingites hate gay people.
Unfortunately, an anti-homosexual
group from Topeka, Kan., plans to demonstrate at Matt's funeral. Rev. Fred
Phelps of the Wesboro Baptist Church issured faxes Monday condemning the
victim, Matt Shepard, for being gay. In a telephone in terview, an
agitated Phelps said he didn't care that his planned demonstration would
upset those who attend Matt's funeral. The fax displayed examples of
"preaching" signs the church say they plan to show at the
demonstration, some of which read "God hat es fags," "No
tears for queers," and "Fag Matt in hell."
"What ought to make that
family sad is the fact that they frittered away the opportunity to raise
up a child in the nurturihg admonition of the Lord," said the
67-year-old misister, a well-known anti-gay activist in Kansas, where
demonst rations outside funerals are outlawed." Of course, here in
wonderful Wyoming we don't have such a law!
Hating the sin and loving the
sinner makes great political and religious rhetoric. But it's a
distinction that fails to be made every day across America and, in
particular, one cold night in Wyoming.
Tue Oct 13, 1998 - 12:00PM EDT
- JEFFERSON REPORT EDITORIAL ON SHEPARD
"The Jefferson Report" -- 10/13/98
Hating The Sinner
Well, so much for hating the sin
and loving the sinner. It seems that Russell Henderson and Aaron McKinney
weren't able to make this religious and intellectual distinction when they
abducted a gay college student last week by pretending they were also gay.
The two allegedly pistol-whipped the student, Matthew Shepard, tied him
spread-eagle to a fence, tortured him and bashed his skull with the butt
of a handgun before leaving him to die in the freezing Wyoming night.
If this description of how
Shepard was killed doesn't just scream "hating the sinner"
nothing does. But then again, the two who are accused of the murder
don't appear to be shining examples of America's youth who can appreciate
the distinction between a person and a person's behavior.
Both are high school dropouts.
One lives with his girl friend and the other has fathered a child with his
18-year old girl friend. Even committing a less serious crime seemed
to be acceptable to the two men since, according to one of the girl
friends involved, the men simply set out to rob Shepard of his money
because they thought he had made a pass at one of them the night before in
a bar.
Hating the sin and loving the
sinner makes great political and religious rhetoric. But it's a
distinction that fails to be made every day across America and, in
particular, one cold night in Wyoming.
(For a FREE e-mail subscription
to "The Jefferson Report", a syndicated daily radio commentary,
send "subscribe" message to Robert Jefferson at Jeffreport@scsn.net.
Reprint with permission only. Visit "The Jefferson Report"
web page: http://www.jeffersonreport.com/)
Tue Oct 13, 1998 - 1:30AM EDT
- WYOMING GOVERNOR MAKES DISTURBING STATEMENTS RE: HATE CRIME LAW
SUPPORTERS
The Governor of Wyoming, Jim Geringer, has vacillated over the last few
days as to whether he does or does not support passing hate crimes
legislation as a results of Matthew's brutal assault and murder. ABC
News said tonight with regards to a hate crime law, "the governor
says he's still not convinced the state needs one." The
governor was then shown on camera apparently commenting on those who
support the adoption of hate crimes laws: "we shouldn't be running
off as a lynch mob might trying to look for vigilante justice, because
that would be just as wrong as the act we deplore already." A
statement from the governor's office, in which he again criticizes hate
crimes laws, is located below. The governor's email address is: <Governor@missc.state.wy.us>.
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 11:50PM EDT
- HOMECOMING PARADE MOCKS SHEPARD
According to the Associated Press, Colorado State University officials are
investigating how a scarecrow that mocked homosexuals showed up on a
homecoming parade float while a gay man lay dying in a local hospital. The
parade took place Saturday. That same day, Matthew Shepard lay dying in
Poudre Valley Hospital five miles across town. The bicyclists who
found Matthew at first mistook him for a scarecrow. The scarecrow
appeared on a float sponsored by Pi Kappa Alpha fraternity and Alpha Chi
Omega sorority. Nicholas Haws, homecoming chairman for Pi Kappa Alpha,
said the scarecrow was supposed to be in the uniform of the Tulsa
University's Golden Hurricane, Colorado State's opponents in Saturday's
football game. He said someone vandalized the float Friday night,
pinning a sign saying ``I am Gay'' and an anti-gay epithet on the figure.
He said the scarecrow was removed but someone placed it back on the float
prior to Saturday's parade.
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 11:45PM EDT
- NOTE FROM ELLEN DEGENERES' MOM
There will be a vigil on the steps of the Capitol in Washington, D.C., on
Wednesday, Oct. 14, at 6 p.m. to honor Matthew Shepard.
Betty DeGeneres wrote:
Anne, Ellen and I are flying there for it and want as many people as can
possibly get there to take part -- gay people, straight people, families
-- everyone with love and acceptance of their fellow man in their hearts.
This is to honor the brief life of Matthew Shepard.
Thanks, Betty DeGeneres
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 11:40PM EDT
- CLINTON STATEMENT ON SHEPARD
THE WHITE HOUSE
Office of the Press Secretary
For Immediate Release
October 12, 1998
REMARKS BY THE PRESIDENT
UPON DEPARTURE FOR NEW YORK
The South Lawn
3:02 P.M. EDT
Let me also take a moment here to
offer my prayers and my condolences to the family of Matthew Shepard, as
well as to the community of Laramie, Wyoming and the university.
While it wouldn't be proper for me to comment on the specifics of this
case I do want to say again, crimes of hate and crimes of violence cannot
be tolerated in our country. In our shock and grief one thing must
remain clear, hate and prejudice are not American values. The public
outrage in Laramie and all across America today echoes what we heard at
the White House Conference on Hate Crimes last year -- there is something
we can do about this, Congress needs to pass our tough Hate Crimes
Legislation. It can do so even before it adjourns and it should do
so.
I hope that in the grief of this
moment for Matthew Shepard's family, and in the shared outrage across
America, American's will once again search their hearts and do what they
can to reduce their own fear and anxiety and anger at people who are
different. And I hope that Congress will pass the Hate Crimes
Legislation.
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 11:00PM EDT
- MATTHEW'S FUNERAL, FINAL HEALTH SUMMARY, FAMILY STATEMENT
Monday, October 12, 1998
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MATTHEW SHEPARD MEDICAL UPDATE for 10:30 a.m. October 12, 1998
NOTICE: The funeral service date has changed due to new information.
Funeral arrangements have been
made for Matthew Shepard. Services will be held at Saint Mark's Episcopal
Church in Casper, Wyoming on Friday, October 16th at 1:30 p.m. Family and
friends will be given priority seating and others will be accommodated as
space permits. No further information is available at this time.
#
MATTHEW SHEPARD MEDICAL UPDATE for 4:30 a.m. October 12, 1998
The following information was
released by Rulon Stacey, CEO and president of Poudre Valley Hospital, at
a press conference at 4:30 a.m. October 12 at the hospital.
At 12 midnight on Monday, October
12, Matthew Shepard's blood pressure began to drop. We immediately
notified his family who were already at the hospital.
At 12:53 a.m. Matthew Shepard
died, his family was at his bedside.
Summary:
Matthew arrived at 9:15 p.m. Wednesday, October 7, in critical condition.
Matthew remained in critical condition during his entire stay at Poudre
Valley Hospital.
During his stay, efforts to improve his condition proved to no avail.
Matthew died while on full life support measures.
Funeral arrangements are pending, and we will announce those arrangements
on our website as soon as they are available at www.pvhs.org, under the
PVHS NEWS toolbar. Please do not call the hospital for this information;
we will post the information on this web site as soon as we find out.
The family did release the
following statement, "We would like to thank the hospital for their
kindness, professionalism, sympathy, and respect for the needs of our
family under this stressful time. We will always be grateful for their
concern for Matthew."
The family again asked me to
express their sincere gratitude to the entire world for the overwhelming
response for their son. During the last 24 hours we have received nearly
2000 e-mails from every continent, and, our Website, which normally
receives 100 hits a day, received thousands of hits on Saturday and
Sunday. We will continue to forward to the family any e-mail we receive.
The e-mail address is mshepard@libra.pvh.org.
The family has again asked that
no flowers be sent but rather that people send donations to the Matthew
Shepard memorial fund at:
c/o First National Bank
PO Box 578
Fort Collins, CO 80522
Account No. 1926083
The family was grateful they did
not have to make a decision regarding whether or not to continue life
support for their son. Like a good son, he was caring to the end and
removed guilt or stress from the family. He came into the world
premature and left the world premature. Matthew's mother said,
"Go home, give your kids a hug and don't let a day go by without
telling them you love them." Matthew's family is so grateful
that his last words to them were, "I love you." This was said
when the family went to Saudi Arabia where they work for an oil company.
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 10:20PM EDT
- NATIONAL GAY GROUPS PLAN EVENT AT US CAPITOL BUILDING
GLAADLINES
Contact: Liz Tracey, GLAAD Publications Manager
(212) 807-1700 x18
tracey@glaad.org
http://www.glaad.org
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: October
12, 1998
News and Breaking Stories about the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender
Community
SPECIAL GLAADLINES EDITION ON THE DEATH OF MATTHEW SHEPARD
DEATH OF WYOMING MAN SPURS
RENEWED FIGHT FOR HATE CRIMES LEGISLATION: The death of Matthew Shepard,
the 21-year-old University of Wyoming student who sustained massive
injuries in a brutal attack last week, has galvanized the lesbian, gay
bisexual and transgender community in seeking hate crimes legislation that
covers bias crimes based on sexual orientation and identity. Shepard, who
was found October 7 after nearly 20 hours of being tied to a fence and
left to die, had been beaten, bludgeoned and slashed and was hospitalized
in Fort Collins, Colorado's Poudre Valley Hospital until his death on
October 12. Shepard was allegedly targeted in a bar popular among
gay men by 21-year-old Russell Arthur Henderson and 20-year-old Aaron
James McKinney.
A press conference will be held
tomorrow, October 13, 1998 at 12:30 p.m. on the steps of the Albany County
courthouse in Laramie, Wyoming, to call for hate crimes legislation which
would enable prosecutors to seek substantial additional penalties when
charging those who commit crimes motivated by bias. Among those attending
the conference will be Wyoming State Rep. Wende Barker, Cathy Renna, GLAAD
Director of Community Relations, and Dan Hawes, Field Organizer for the
National Lesbian and Gay Task Force.
GLAAD executive director Joan M.
Garry pointed out that Shepard's murder took place on the heels of the
announcement by the Center For Reclaiming America and the Family Research
Council that they would be launching a series of television ads building
on their anti-gay newspaper campaign this summer, which promised
"hope and healing." Speaking about the Wyoming incident, Garry
observed, "If you think homophobic advertisements like those which
ran in our newspapers this summer are devoid of repercussions - think
again. These ads give people permission to hate."
On Wednesday, October 14,
at 7:00 p.m., the Human Rights Campaign (HRC), National Lesbian and Gay
Task Force (NGLTF) and GLAAD, as well as entertainment figures Helen Hunt,
Ellen DeGeneres, her mother Betty Degeneres and Elton John (not yet
confirmed at press time) will join on the steps of the U.S. Capitol in
Washington, D.C.. They will remember Matthew Shepard and renew the call
for the passage of the Hate Crimes Prevention Act by Congress, which
President Clinton first called for over a year ago. Elizabeth Birch,
executive director of HRC, commented "There is nothing special about
living a life free of violence and nothing right about opposing laws that
would help remedy this situation. Those who oppose hate crimes legislation
are either burying their heads in the sand or they simply don't care that
thousands of gay and lesbian Americans are being harassed and brutalized
each year."
A website administered by Wired
Strategies, a political Internet consulting firm, has been set up to serve
as a clearinghouse for information and coverage of the murder of Matthew
Shepard. Among the resources are an e-mail distribution list, an online
discussion forum, summaries and transcripts of stories reported on the
murder, and an extensive list of recent bias crimes committed against
lesbian, gay bisexual and transgender
individuals over the past year. The URL address is http://www.wiredstrategies.com/shepard.html
. To subscribe to the e-mail list, send an e-mail to john@wiredstrategies.com
with your e-mail address in the body of the message.
For more information about the
Wyoming press conference, contact Cathy Renna, GLAAD Director of Community
Relations at (202) 957-8317. For information regarding the Washington D.C.
press conference, contact Wayne Besen of the Human Rights Campaign at
(202) 216-1580. For information about national and state hate crimes
legislation and statistics contact Jeffrey Montgomery of the National
Coalition of Anti-Violence Programs, at (313) 537-3323 or Tracey Conaty,
Communications Director for the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force, at
(202) 332-6483 x3303.
GLAAD is the nation's lesbian
& gay multimedia advocacy organization. GLAAD promotes fair, accurate,
and inclusive representation as a means of challenging discrimination
based on sexual orientation or identity. To subscribe contact Wonbo Woo at
(212) 807-1700 or at woo@glaad.org. "GLAAD" and "Gay
& Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation" are registered trademarks
of the Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation, Inc.
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 10:00PM EDT
- NATIONAL YOUTH ADVOCACY COALITION STATEMENT
PRESS STATEMENT ON WYOMING ATTACK - National Youth Advocacy Coalition
CONTACT: Rea Carey
Executive Director
1711 Connecticut Avenue, NW
Suite 206
Washington, DC 20009
888/694-7172 (pager)
202/319-7596, x15 (phone)
rcarey@nyacyouth.org (email)
____________________________________________________________
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
October 10, 1998
NATIONAL GAY YOUTH GROUP CALLS ON
COUNTRY TO WAKE UP TO VIOLENCE FACED BY MATTHEW SHEPARD AND OTHER GAY
YOUTH
THIS WEEK'S WHITE HOUSE CONFERENCE ON SCHOOL SAFETY COMES AT IMPORTANT
TIME
The following statement is attributable to Rea Carey, Executive Director,
National Youth Advocacy Coalition:
"The National Youth Advocacy
Coalition finds the attack on University of Wyoming student Matthew
Shepard brutish, disgusting and a frightening reflection of the violence
faced by gay youth. This horrendous beating, burning, and torture is
one stop on the clear continuum of violence and harassment faced by our
nation's young people. Starting with name calling in elementary
schools and ending in murder on our nation's streets and rural roads, the
threats to safety for gay youth have been tolerated for far too long.
It is time our nation's leaders and communities took a stand against the
extreme mistreatment of gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender youth.
Wyoming Governor Jim Geringer's
call this week for hate crimes legislation is admirable but comes too late
for Matthew Shepard. Somewhere along the way, his attackers got the
message that it is acceptable to beat, burn, and rob a young gay man.
Past opponents of the inclusion of 'sexual orientation' in hate crimes
legislation argued that its passage would give 'special rights' to gays.
It seems to me that Matthew Shepard could have used any rights the night
he was tied to a fence and beaten. Anti-gay forces will have to be
very creative in coming up with an argument for not passing hate crimes
legislation next time around. Their excuses will fall on angry ears.
It is time for the State of Wyoming and our country to right its past
wrongs.
This week, I will be attending
the White House Conference on School Safety with other advocates for safe
learning environments. This conference comes at a critical time as
our nation struggles with violent attacks on this country's students at
the hands of their peers. Although Matthew Shepard is a college
student, his attack is, unfortunately, representative of the continuum of
violence and harassment faced by gay youth beginning in grade school.
The National Youth Advocacy Coalition calls on our nation's
decision-makers, the White House, and communities across the country to
open their eyes to the day to day realities of gay, lesbian, bisexual and
transgender youth. Our country can not afford to lose one more life
at the hands of homophobic youth and the laws, systems and beliefs that
support them."
FACTS ABOUT GAY YOUTH:
* 80% of gay, lesbian and bisexual youth report verbal abuse (1)
* 44% of gay, lesbian and bisexual youth report threats of attack (1)
* 17% of gay, lesbian and bisexual youth have been assaulted (1)
* 66.7% of gay, lesbian and bisexual youth were threatened/injured with a
weapon at school in the past year (2)
* 20.1% of gay, lesbian and bisexual youth skipped school in the past
month because of feeling unsafe on route to or at school (2)
* 62.3 % of gay, lesbian and bisexual youth were in a physical fight in
the past year (2)
NOTES:
(1) AR D'Augelli, HDFS, Pennsylvania State, University Park, PA, 16802.
(814)865-2649.
(2) Massachusetts Youth Risk Behavior Survey, 1995. Conducted by the US
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
The National Youth Advocacy
Coalition is the only national organization solely focused on advocacy,
education, and information addressing the broad range of issues facing
gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender youth. NYAC works to end
discrimination against these young people and to ensure their physical and
emotional well being. NYAC represents the interests of GLBT youth
and the over 500 organizations nationwide providing support services to
GLBT youth.
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 7:40PM EDT
- STATEMENT FROM JESUS RIOS, UNIV OF WY STUDENT PRESIDENT
Friends and fellow students of the University of Wyoming ask for your
support in remembering Matthew Shepard. We have made and distributed
over 3,000 yellow armbands with green circles in our community alone, and
encourage every community to do the same. It is to remember the
tragedy which has occured on our campus, and to encourage the political
fight which Matthew himself was a part of. We ask that all
institutions of higher education seek out all institutional policies to
include equality on the basis of sexual orientation, and that they take an
active role in educating students, faculty and staff. We encourage
all to write their congress and DEMAND that Hate-Crime legislation be
written and passed. We do not wish to make Matthew a martyr but we
continue to fight for national support on these matters in his name and
ask for your support!
For those of you who have
wondered what exactly Wyoming is all about or what they intend to do let
me inform you of the following. First, this incident is not typical
of Wyoming mentality. We have been scrutinized by some on not being
"The Equality State," but this is merely perceptual.
Wyoming maintains its vigilant standards for acceptance and equality,
despite perceptions. Now as for what we are doing.
The University of Wyoming
students are fully supporting the (LGBTA) Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual,
Transgender association in their events this current week. We have planned
vigils, a remembrance ceremony to be held today in light of his death, and
a funeral service to be held on campus early next week. The
President of the University has ordered the campus flag to be flown at
half-mast till his funeral service. We continue to plan for
education seminars to be held in classes through out the week and weeks to
come. We are also in the process of writing a resolution to
encourage the State to enact Hate-Crime legislation. Any other
concerns or questions that anyone may have can contact the ASUW Student
Govt. office at 766-5204, or Jesus Rios, the ASUW President at ASUWPRES@uwyo.edu.
Thank you for caring about Matthew Shepard and for his cause.
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 6:55PM EDT
- LAMBDA LEGAL DEFENSE FUND SPEAKS OUT
LAMBDA LEGAL DEFENSE AND EDUCATION FUND
www.lambdalegal.org
Statement
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Monday, October 12, 1998
Contact: Peg Byron 212-809-8585 x230, 888-987-1984 (pager)
Tragic Death of Gay Wyoming
Student Begs for End to Hatemongering
Oldest and largest gay legal group says anti-gay discrimination fuels
violence
(NEW YORK, October 12, 1998) --
Responding to the death of Matthew Shepard on Monday, Lambda Legal Defense
and Education Fund said anti-gay violence goes hand in hand with the
hatemongering and prejudice commonly voiced by anti-gay extremists,
including some public officials around the country.
"This University of Wyoming
student was beaten and left to die, tied to a fence like an animal,
because he was honest and open about being gay. Matthew Shepard's
horrible suffering and death cannot be dismissed simply as the fault of
deranged, isolated individuals. His attackers are among millions of
Americans who constantly hear the message that gay people are not worthy
of the most basic equal treatment," said Lambda Legal Director
Beatrice Dohrn.
"By simply being ourselves
and saying there's nothing wrong with us because we are gay, we risk
everything --- from our lives to our jobs or custody of our children.
The first step in ending this kind of violence, which took Matthew's life,
is to end anti-gay discrimination and the hostility that it fosters.
"For example, with the
Military's 'don't ask, don't tell,' the United States government continues
to insist that troops cannot be expected to accept service members who are
openly gay," Dohrn said.
"In Hawaii, and elsewhere in
the country, Lambda also is fighting for the freedom for gay couples to
marry and for basic respect for our families. At the U.S.
Supreme Court, Lambda is urging an end to a sweeping anti-gay initiative
from Cincinnati, that was supported by some of the same extremist groups
now promoting anti-gay newspaper and television advertisements around the
country."
Noting that reported anti-gay
violence last year increased a dramatic 34 percent at schools and
colleges, according to the National Coalition of Anti-Violence Programs,
Dohrn said, "In Utah, Lambda continues a court battle with
school officials who actually refuse to allow students at a Salt Lake City
school to organize against anti-gay brutality and harassment."
"Gaybashers do not make
subtle distinctions between calls for anti-gay discrimination and anti-
gay violence," Dohrn said, adding, "It is well past time for
public officials and extremists to take responsibility for the hurt they
promote against gay people and to join us in seeking equal treatment for
all."
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 6:10PM EDT
- GLAAD, NGLTF AND LOCAL GROUPS TO HOLD PRESS CONFERENCE
GLAAD
MEDIA ADVISORY
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Mike Massie, Wyoming
State Representative (D-Laramie) - phone: (307) 766-5096
Cathy Renna, GLAAD Director of Community Relations - cell: (202) 957-8317
- pager: (917) 240-3710
LOCAL AND NATIONAL GROUPS CALL
FOR HATE CRIME LEGISLATION FOLLOWING BRUTAL WYOMING MURDER
PRESS CONFERENCE TO PRECEDE
PRELIMINARY HEARING OF SUSPECTS
LARAMIE, WY, MONDAY, OCTOBER 12,
1998-On Tuesday, October 13, Wyoming State Representative Wende Barker
(D-Laramie); spokespersons from statewide and national lesbian, gay,
bisexual and transgender organizations including the Gay & Lesbian
Alliance Against Defamation (GLAAD) and the National Gay and Lesbian Task
Force (NGLTF); and a close friend of Matthew Shepard, who died early this
morning after having been viciously attacked, stabbed, burned and left for
dead last week in an anti-gay attack, will speak out on the desperate need
for hate crimes legislation on the state and federal levels. The press
conference will be held just prior to the preliminary hearing of the
alleged attackers at the Albany County Courthouse.
"Because of homophobic
attitudes, every attempted bias crime bill so far to be proposed in the
state legislature has been blocked," said State Representative Mike
Massie (D-Laramie). "The viciousness of the attack on Matt clearly
shows how critical this kind of legislation is. The attack was fueled by
the kind of ignorance and intolerance that we as Americans must condemn in
the strongest terms possible."
Matt's close friend Hauva
Manookin added, "As devastated as we are by this tragedy, we know
this embodies Matt's commitment to justice and human rights. I hope that
hate crimes legislation will be passed so that some sense can come from
this tragedy."
WHO:
Wyoming State Representative Wende Barker, Walt Boulden of United Gays and
Lesbians of Wyoming, National Gay and Lesbian Task Force Field Organizer
Dan Hawes, GLAAD Director of Community Relations Cathy Renna and
University of Wyoming Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Association
Treasurer Hauva Manookin
WHAT:
Press conference of statewide and national organizations on the desperate
need for state and national hate crime legislation.
WHEN:
Tuesday, October 13, 1998 at 12:30 p.m.
WHERE:
Albany County Courthouse, Grand Ave. between 5th and 6th Sts. (Laramie)
Courthouse Rotunda, 2nd Floor
For more information about hate
crimes legislation, please visit the website of the National Gay &
Lesbian Task Force (NGLTF), located online at: http://www.ngltf.org, or
contact Tracey Conaty, NGLTF Communications Director at (202) 332-6483
x3303.
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 5:30PM EDT-
HRC STATEMENT ON MATTHEW'S DEATH
WYOMING GAY BASHING VICTIM MATTHEW SHEPARD PRONOUNCED DEAD
HRC Mourns The Loss Of Brave Student Who Stood Up To Intolerance
WASHINGTON -- Matthew Shepard, 21, the gay University of
Wyoming student who was savagely attacked Thursday night, burned, and left
to die for up to 18 hours tied to a wooden fence outside Laramie, 30 miles
northwest of Cheyenne, was pronounced dead this morning.
"With a profound sense of
sorrow we mourn the death of Matthew Shepard. We are deeply saddened by
this tragedy and we offer our thoughts and prayers to the Shepard
family," said HRC Executive Director Elizabeth Birch.
Shepard died while on life
support. He had been in a coma since he was found on Thursday by
passing motorcyclists. Wyoming's Republican Governor Jim Geringer
called on state legislators to adopt laws to deter crimes against lesbians
and gay men.
"We are calling on all the
people to have a renewed discussion to find out what we might do to
strengthen our laws. I'm open to any suggestion that we might bring
to our legislature," said Gov. Geringer to the Associated
Press.
Two men, Russell Arthur
Henderson, 21, and Aaron James McKinney, whose age is unconfirmed, were
charged with kidnaping aggravated robbery, and attempted first degree
murder and held on $100,000 bond. University of Wyoming student,
Chastity Vera Pasley, 20 and Kristen Leann Price, 18, were charged
as accessories to the crime. Price was released on $30,000 bond and
Pasely is still in jail in lieu of the same amount of money.
"Matthew was not very
large, at 5'2" 110 pounds, but he had a big heart and was extremely
brave. He had the courage to live honestly and openly in less than
ideal circumstances. Unfortunately, like many gay men and lesbians,
there is often a high price to pay for living a life of dignity and
respect," said HRC political director Winnie Stachelberg.
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 5:13PM EDT
- WYOMING GOVERNOR CRITICIZES HATE CRIMES LAWS
The Governor of Wyoming released a statement today condemning Matthew's
murder, then turned around and criticized hate crimes laws: "If hate
is involved as a motive, it can make the penalty more severe. That helps
little, if the victim is dead." Wyoming is one of 8 states
without a hate crime law. And the idea behind hate crimes laws is
not only to punish your murderer after you're dead, it's to send a message
from the highest levels of government that hate crimes will not be
tolerated, so that criminals and bigots get the message that such actions
are wrong before they happen, hopefully avoiding them
altogether. Using the Governor's logic, one wonders whether we
should criminalize murder at all, since it helps little to punish the
criminal if the victim is already dead. With such statements of
"concern" coming from the highest office in Wyoming, Lord help
the rest of Wyoming's gay community, and us all.
Click
here to email the governor and tell him your thoughts.
The Governor's statement:
STATE OF WYOMING
OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR
JIM GERINGER
GOVERNOR STATE CAPITOL
CHEYENNE, WYOMING
For Release: October 12, 1998 Contact: Jimmy Orr 777.7437
Comments by Governor Jim Geringer on the Matthew Shepard Incident
I am deeply saddened to hear of Matthew Shepard's death. We all feel a
sense of tragedy and disbelief that a human life could be taken in such a
brutal way.
We send our comfort and prayers
to Matthew's parents, family and friends. May they find strength to carry
on in spite of this terrible act. We now must find closure, to first
assure that justice will be effectively carried out, and second to work
with t he determination that there will not be a repeat of this incident
in any fashion in Wyoming.
The message that should go out is
that no one is above the law, that no life or freedom should be taken
simply by an act of prejudice. The young people charged must now realize
that their lives are permanently changed. They have irreversibly altered
the ir future, if indeed, they even have one.
The overwhelming reaction of the
people I've visited with is one of shock that such a brutal attack could
happen in Wyoming. With the resulting national media reaction, Wyoming
people are discouraged that all of us could be unfairly stereotyped by the
ac tions of two very sick and twisted people.
The magnitude of the national
response indicates that this is an issue of concern all over America, but
perhaps in a special way for Wyoming, because "Wyoming is What
America Was." How will Wyoming handle the situation? Wyoming is still
"The Last Best Place" and "The Equality State." Can we
serve as a model on how to deal with brutality so that the rest of America
can deal with its own insensitivity? Yes, we can. But how?
Recalling the horror, rejecting
terror, refusing to be drawn in by prejudice is not enough. If all we feel
is outrage, we have no remedy. If we don't feel ashamed, we will not
change. If we don't speak out for truth, we will not preserve it.
In order to practice Wyoming's
motto of "The Equality State," we must acknowledge each other's
worth and dignity or we will lose our basic values. Friday's incident can
serve as a remembrance of how not to act.
But this is not just an issue
over sexual orientation. This is about hate and misdirected values. Any
taking of a life is wrong. Any act that would exert terrorism is wrong.
Every spring I am asked to participate in a "Day of Remembrance"
to memoriali ze the victims of the Holocaust of World War II, for those
who fought for equality, who felt the rejection of prejudice. The memorial
is always a look back at events that should never be repeated. It is also
a look forward, with renewed commitment not only to fight against
prejudice, hatred or intolerance, but also to practice equality.
The terrible actions taken by the
Hitler regime in Nazi Germany did not take place suddenly, as a single
event. The German people and their public institutions slipped slowly but
steadily into accepting, while not preventing, crimes against Jewish peopl
e. Hatred begins in small incremental ways. How many times have each of us
failed through words or actions to correct an injustice? How often do we
stereotype people rather than acknowledge individual uniqueness?
Unanswered criticism.
Unchallenged accusations. Each becomes a tacit validation, a passive
approval of a lie.
Even the national reaction to
Wyoming is in part a stereotype. The clamoring for Wyoming to pass a
"hate crimes law" reflects a rush to judgement in itself. We can
and will deal with this properly and on our own. Those who call for a
nationally imposed remedy are misdirected.
I note with irony that the
national press didn't bat an eye when young Kristin Lamb was abducted from
her grandparent's front yard, raped, murdered and dumped in a landfill.
That action is just as repulsive as the loss of Matthew Shepard.
We should now make this an
opportunity to remind each other of what went wrong in the past so that we
might bring what is right to the future. We must never forget the tragedy
of a discarded people, whether it be through extermination camps or by our
own individual disregard for others.
The issue in this case happens to
be homosexuality, but hate knows no boundary. Any act that displays a lack
of respect for human life is wrong. How should Wyoming deal with hate
crime legislation? What are anti-bias or anti-hate laws?
I've asked several proponents of
hate crime legislation to describe where Wyoming's laws are deficient.
What I've found is that most don't even know what Wyoming's laws are. The
fact is, Wyoming laws are already quite strict. But we can and should pro
vide for more options for local law enforcement and our judiciary so that
we can deal with future situations.
I read with interest Chuck
Green's editorial in the Denver Post. He commented on what a hate crime
law could include. Such laws don't make hate itself a crime, but they
consider whether hate as a motivating factor in a crime, is an aggravating
factor w hen the charges are brought and tried. If hate is involved as a
motive, it can make the penalty more severe. That helps little, if the
victim is dead. You can only impose capital punishment once. Hate though,
could be considered as an aggravating circ umstance when a jury considers
whether the death penalty is appropriate.
Burn a cross on a black family's
lawn, and it's more serious than setting their trash can on fire. Paint a
swastika on a Jewish family's car, and it's more serious than painting a
gang sign on a warehouse wall. Assault a homosexual because his sexual
orie ntation offends you, and it's more serious than if you assaulted
someone at the office. The difference is measured in motive, not in
action. Hate is anarchy in a country that was founded on democracy.
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 3:00PM EDT
- TELL CONGRESS "ENOUGH ALREADY!"
The US Congress is refusing to pass legislation that would permit the FBI
to investigate attacks against gays and lesbians such as the brutal murder
of Matthew Shepard.
The Hate Crimes Prevention Act (HCPA),
H.R.3081 and S.1529, would amend current federal law to include real Or
perceived sexual orientation, gender, and disability so the FBI would be
able to investigate and prosecute violent hate crimes against gays,
lesbians, and bisexuals. Current law already allows investigation and
Prosecution on the basis of race, religion, national origin and color, but
doesn't include sexual orientation.
Please email your US Senators
and House Members and
tell them to pass the federal Hate Crimes Prevention Act (H.R.3081 and
S.1529) immediately - and don't forget to sign the email with your name
and address (the Web links above will assist you in identifying and
emailing your Member of Congress). Also, call the Congressional
switchboard at 202/224-3121 and ask for your Member's office, then tell
them to pass the Act as well. Congress will likely close up for the
year in the next few days - don't let them leave Washington without
passing this bill in Matthew's name.
Draft email:
Dear XXXXX:
I am writing to urge you to pass the Hate Crimes
Prevention Act (H.R.3081 and S.1529). As you know, Matthew Shepard
was brutally tied up, tortured, pistol-whipped and then left to die in
Wyoming because he was gay. Wyoming does not have a hate crimes law
- and only 21 states and the District of Columbia include sexual
orientation-based crimes in their hate crimes statutes.
The FBI may not have jurisdiction to investigate the
Shepard case without passage of the Hate Crimes Act. You can change
that sad fact. With hate crimes against gay men and lesbians on the
rise last year, while crime overall decreased, it is imperative that
Congress stand up to hate and violence and pass the Hate Crimes Prevention
Act now.
Thank you,
NAME AND ADDRESS
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 10:55AM EDT
- UNIVERSITY OF WYOMING POSTS STATEMENTS TO WEB
The University of Wyoming has
posted new information on their home page regarding Matthew's death.
The information includes: a statement from the Candlelight Vigil for
Matthew Shepard, Oct. 11, 1998; Statement by Philip L. Dubois, President,
University of Wyoming; Statement by Jesus Rios, President, Associated
Students - University of Wyoming; Statement by James Osborn, Chair,
Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgendered Association, University of Wyoming;
and information regarding the Benefit Fund for Matthew Shepard. I
will review this information shortly and perhaps post some on this site.
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 10:11AM EDT
- MATTHEW HAS DIED
Monday October 12 9:39 AM EDT
Gay Wyoming College Student Dies
After Beating
FORT COLLINS, Colo. (Reuters) - A University of Wyoming student savagely
beaten in an apparent hate crime because he was gay died early Monday, a
Colorado hospital said.
Rulon Stacey, chief executive
officer of the Poudre Valley Health System, told reporters Matthew
Shepard, 21, died at 12:53 a.m. MDT (2:53 a.m. EDT) Monday. His family was
at his bedside.
Shepard had been breathing with
the aid of a ventilator since being found last Wednesday night beaten and
tied for some 18 hours to a wooden fence where he was left to die just
outside Laramie, Wyoming, a small college town.
He suffered a severe skull
fracture and was burned in the attack. Police said the college student
begged for his life.
Shepard was found by a passing
motorist who at first thought that the figure on a fence post was a
scarecrow.
He died of his injuries rather
than being removed from life support by his parents, Stacey said.
``They did not have to come to a
point in the process where they were forced to make a decision. Life
support remained with Matthew throughout the process,'' Stacey said.
``In fact they said (as) the
caring son that he was, he was able to remove from them the guilt or
stress of having to make that decision,'' said the hospital administrator,
nearly breaking into tears.
His parents, Judy and Dennis
Shepard, flew to Colorado from Saudi Arabia where the father works in the
oil industry. Stacey said the parents were overwhelmed by the outpouring
of support for their son.
Two men are in custody for the
attack and their girlfriends, who allegedly provided them an alibi and
helped hide bloody clothes, have been charged as accessories after the
fact.
Police following the attack
lodged attempted first-degree murder charges against the two men and said
the charges could be upgraded.
The attack on Shepard, who
reportedly lived an openly gay life, was condemned by President Clinton
and the governor of Wyoming as well as ordinary citizens who appeared at
vigils in honor of the student.
Police believe robbery as well as
gay bashing was a motivation in the crime.
Bill McKinney, the father of
suspect Aaron McKinney, and Kristen Price, Aaron's girlfriend who was also
charged in the case, have said the two men accused of the attack targeted
Shepard because he had flirted with Aaron McKinney at a bar and
embarrassed him, a published report said Sunday.
The attack in Laramie, Wyoming, a
small western town with a popular of 26,000, stunned residents and
prompted calls for more anti-hate crime legislation.
The hospital had been flooded
with flowers and Rulon said messages from people came from around the
world and were in the thousands.
Mon Oct 12, 1998 - 12:43AM EDT
- SUSPECT'S FATHER DENIES HATE CRIME
Reuters
reported on Sunday October 11 at 12:14AM that Bill McKinney, the
father of murder suspect Aaron McKinney, denied that the attack on Matthew
Shepard was a hate crime, arguing that Matthew "embarrassed" his
son. Doctors are saying that it is still too early to know if
Matthew will recover. McKinney's father say that Shepard
"flirted" with his son at the bar where they met, and that this
"embarrassed" his son. Reuters also reported that Bill
McKinney told ABC News that his son had confessed to the crime and didn't
want to live [I watched ABC News tonight, taped the broadcast, and heard
nothing of the sort.] According to Reuters, "Bill McKinney told
the newspaper there was no excuse for what his son is accused of doing,
but said the attack did not warrant national attention."
McKinney was quoted as saying "Had this been a heterosexual these two
boys decided to take out and rob, this never would have made the national
news."
Personal commentary from John of
Wired Strategies:
It is unclear to me how pistol-whipping, burning, torturing and then
leaving a man to die, tied unconscious, spread-eagle, bleeding with a
crushed skull in 30-degree weather for 12 hours is a normal proportionate
reaction to being "embarrassed," even by, dare I say the word, a
homosexual. It is this kind of "he deserved it" attitude
that led to Matthew's savage attack in the first place, and is a common
staple of hate crime cases. As for the father's assertion that 'had
the victim been a heterosexual, the attack would have never made the
news,' I have two responses. First, his boy did not take someone out
and "rob" them, he conducted a savage crucifixion-style lynching
which, outside of the McKinney residence, would in fact likely make
national news, even if done to a straight man. Second, a friend of
mine put it best, "had they done this to a heterosexual woman who had
'embarrassed' them in a bar, they'd be dead by now." But for
the grace of their pulverizing a gay man do they avoid vigilante justice.
Sun Oct 11, 1998 - 11:10PM EDT - ABC INTERVIEWS GIRLFRIEND AND FATHER
OF ASSAILANT
ABC's World News Tonight, 6:30PM EDT - paraphrase of the broadcast, with
exact quotes:
Matthew Shepard, 21 years old, remains in critical condition, left for
dead in a field. Two men are under arrest, and their girlfriends
have been charged as accessories. One girlfriend, 18 year old
Kristen Price (live-in girlfriend of accused killer Aaron McKinney) tells
the story: "he (McKinney) had blood all over him". She
asked what happened, he replied he "thought maybe he had killed
someone....He said he did not mean to do that to him."
According to Price, the two accused attackers were approached by Shepard
in the bar, they were somehow "offended", and decided to rob him
by pretending to be gay. They lured him to their truck, drove him to
a filed, tied him to a fence, and fractured his skull with a gun.
"He said that yeah, had beat him with the butt of the gun," the
Price said, quoting McKinney. "The thought of a gay guy
approaching him and humiliating him....I guess it just set him off."
McKinney's father told ABC: "He's my son, I raised him better than
that, or tried to."
ABC then followed with a second
story on hate crimes:
Refer to hate crimes legislation, ABC opened the report by saying that
"civil rights groups say these days, gays need that protection more
than any other group." 22 states along with Washington, DC
including sexual orientation in their hate crimes laws. 18 have hate
crimes laws that exclude sexual orientation, and 8 have no hate crimes
laws at all, including Wyoming. Winnie Stachelberg with the Human
Rights Campaign told ABC: "We're seeing an increase in hate crimes
directed at the gay and lesbian community, and in fact not just an
increase in the sheer numbers, but the intensity of the violence."
The President condemned the attack and called on lawmakers to pass a
federal hate crimes bill. Elizabeth Coleman of the Anti Defamation
League said that: "Individuals who commit hate crimes against gay
people think that what they're doing is expected by society."
Sun Oct 11, 1998 - 11:10PM EDT
- CNN REPORTS ON SHEPARD CASE
CNN 5PM EDT Broadcast - Paraphrase of the report, with exact quotes noted:
While condemning the attack, Wyoming's residents defended the state as a
fair place. 21 year old Matthew Shepard was found twelves hours
after he was beaten and tortured so badly, passerbys thought he was a
scarecrow. Two suspects have been charged, and at least one
girlfriend is being treated as an accessory. Matthew was tied with
rope, tortured, and then his assailants attempted to kill him with the
butt of a pistol. According to a hospital spokesman, Matthew's skull
was fractured from behind the head to the front of the right ear,
compressing his skull into his brain. Basically, the two guys
pretended to be gay, and lured Matthew outside. One Wyoming resident
told CNN that "if you come to Wyoming and you're gay, you're looking
for trouble." Another resident countered: "Wyoming is not
a hate crime state." A third said: "Homophobia is a
societal problem and we don't need to wait until something horrible
happens for us to recognize its existence." As a result of the
attack, many have called for tougher hate crimes laws. The family
reports that there has been an overwhelming outpouring of support.
[The closing included footage of a candlelight vigil outside Matthew's
hospital] "Outside the hospital, a vigil -- prayers for a young man,
and a life brutalized by hate."
Sun Oct 11, 1998 - 6:16PM EDT
- NO CHANGE IN MATTHEW'S STATUS
At 3:00PM Mountain Time the hospital announced that there was no change in
Matthew's status, he remains in a coma with severe head injuries.
Sun Oct 11, 1998 - 5:13PM EDT
- GAY BASHING IN MICHIGAN
Doug Bradley of Traverse City, Michigan told police he and a friend were
walking down the street on Oct. 2 when two men starting yelling
"faggot" and other expletives. The men them followed them
to his house and beat him up. Bradley suffered a broken nose, cuts
on his head and face and swollen lips. The attackers were only
charged with a misdemeanor because the prosecutor said he couldn't charge
the men with a hate crime because Michigan law does not cover
homosexuality.
Sun Oct 11, 1998 - 1:32PM EDT
- NO CHANGE IN CONDITION/SEND MORE EMAIL
As of 9AM Mountain time (11AM EDT), Matthew was still in critical
condition. The hospital reports that they have already received 250 email
get-wells for Matthew. I think we can and should do better.
Please celebrate National Coming Out Day today by taking a moment and
including Matthew in your thoughts - email Matthew at <mshepard@libra.pvh.org>.
Sun Oct 11, 1998 - 1:11AM EDT
- SEND EMAIL TO MATTHEW AND HIS FAMILY
The hospital has set up an email address for well-wishers to send messages
to Matthew and his parents. Please take a moment to let Matthew and
his family know our thoughts are with them. Matthew's email address
is: <mshepard@libra.pvh.org>
Sun Oct 11, 1998 - 1:11AM EDT
- NEW DETAILS ON MATTHEW'S CONDITION
Matthew Shepard Medical Update
Saturday, October 10, 1998
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MEDICAL UPDATE
October 10, 1998
The following 9 p.m. October 10
medical update was given by Rulon Stacey, President and CEO of Poudre
Valley Health System. This was distributed to members of the media present
at the time at Poudre Valley Hospital and will be FAXed to reporters as
they call until the next medical update is distributed at about 9 a.m.
October 11.
Since our last medical update at
3 p.m. October 10, Matthew Shepard has remained in critical condition.
Matthew is in the surgical-neuro
intensive care unit in our Regional Neuroscience Center located within the
hospital. He remains in critical condition with severe head injuries.
Respiratory support continues to be provided. He remains on a ventilator.
Matthew came to us on October 7
from Ivinson Hospital in Laramie by way of ambulance. He was admitted in
critical condition at approximately 9:15 p.m. October 7. When he arrived,
he was unresponsive and breathing support was being provided.
_________
The following is medical
information from Poudre Valley Hospital. It was released by Rulon Stacey
at the medical update at 3 p.m. October 10.
Matthew’s major injuries upon
arrival consisted of hypothermia and a fracture from behind his head to
just in front of the right ear. This has caused bleeding in the brain, as
well as pressure on the brain. There were also approximately a dozen small
lacerations around his head, face and neck.
Matthew has a massive brain stem
injury. The brain stem controls vital signs, such as heart beat, body
temperature and other involuntary functions.
Matthew’s temperature has
fluctuated over the last 24 hours, ranging from 98 to 106 degrees. We have
had difficulty controlling his temperature.
Hospital actions have included
the surgeon inserting an intraventicular drain into his brain to relieve
pressure by draining spinal fluid. The drain remains in and functional.
We are also continuing to control
Matthew’s temperature. He remains on a ventilator which is assisting his
breathing.
__________
Well-wishers have also sent many
flowers to Matthew. Again, the parents extend their sincere thank you.
The parents ask that, in lieu of
sending flowers, people contribute to a fund that was set up October 9 in
Matthew’s name. Donations can be sent to:
Fund for the Benefit of Matthew
Shepard
c/o First National Bank
P.O. Box 578
Fort Collins, CO 80522
Account No. 1926083.
__________
Matthew’s current medical
condition and selected information from this web site are also recorded on
voice mail: (970) 495-7032. We ask that people, including the media, rely
on the web site and the voice mail to track Matthew’s condition.
Sun Oct 11, 1998 - 1:11AM EDT - MATTHEW'S PARENTS ISSUE STATEMENT
Matthew Shepard Medical Update
Saturday, October 10, 1998
Matthew’s parents arrived at 7
p.m. October 9 and are now at his bed side. The parents and other family
members who are present strongly request no interviews with the media and
they ask that their privacy is respected.
The following statement from the
parents was read to members of the media waiting outside of the hospital
at 6 p.m. October 10. The parents chose not to read the statement, so it
was read by Rulon Stacey, president and CEO of Poudre Valley Health
System, at their request.
"First of all, we want to
thank the American public for their kind thoughts about Matthew and their
fond wishes for his speedy recovery. We appreciate your prayers and good
will, and we know they are something Matthew would appreciate, too.
"Matthew is a very special
person, and everyone can learn important lessons from his life. All of us
who know Matthew see him as he is, a very kind and gentle soul. He is a
strong believer in humanity and human rights. He is a trusting person who
takes everybody at face value and he does not see the bad side of anyone.
"His one intolerance is when
people don’t accept others as they are. He has always strongly felt that
all people are the same—regardless of their sexual preference, race or
religion.
"We know he believes that
all of us are part of the same family called Humanity, and each and
everyone of us should treat all people with respect and dignity, and that
each of us has the right to live a full and rewarding life. That is one
lesson which we are very certain he would share with you, if he could.
"Matthew also feels strongly
about family. He is a loving son, brother and grandson who has made our
own lives much richer and fuller than what we would have experienced
without him.
"Matthew’s life has often
been a struggle in one way or another. He was born prematurely, and he
struggled to survive as an infant. He is physically short in stature but
we believe he is a giant when it comes to respecting the worth of others.
We know that he thinks if he can make one person’s life better in this
world, then he has succeeded. That is a measure of success which Matthew
has always pursued.
"Matthew very much enjoys
the outdoors and camping, and he has always loved acting in the
theatre—he started acting in community theatre at the age of 5. Acting
and the theatre arts are skills at which Matthew excels.
"He knows he’s not the
best athlete in the world but he has a very competitive spirit. One time
he participated in the Wyoming State Games. He had a respectable finish in
a running competition and then he decided to compete in a swimming event.
He did this even though he knew he would likely finish last. Which he did.
Afterwards, he acknowledged to us that he knew his chances of winning were
far from good but he wasn’t going to let that stop him from trying.
That’s Matthew’s lesson for all of us—it’s lesson that we hope
everyone takes to heart.
"Matthew has traveled all
over the world. He speaks three languages: English, German and Italian. He
loves Europe, but he also loves Laramie and the University of Wyoming. We
feel that, if he was giving this statement himself, he would emphasize he
does not want the horrible actions of a few very disturbed individuals to
mar the fine reputations of Laramie or the university.
"Finally, we would like to
thank the sheriff’s department of Albany County, Wyoming, and Poudre
Valley Hospital in Fort Collins for their very professional efforts on
Matthew’s behalf.
"We also have a special
request for the members of the media. Matthew is very much in need of his
family at this time, and we ask that you respect our privacy, as well as
Matthew’s so we can concentrate all of our efforts, thoughts and love on
our son.
"Thank you very much."
__________
Approximately two to three dozen
calls have come into the hospital from people in Colorado and around the
nation who have extended offers of donations and other support, such as
legal and counseling support. The parents extend their very sincere thank
you for these offers of support.
Sat Oct 10, 1998 - 5:40PM EDT
- GREAT STATEMENT FROM HUMAN RIGHTS CAMPAIGN
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Saturday, October 10, 1998
HRC CONDEMNS WYOMING HATE CRIME AND SAYS RELIGIOUS RIGHT'S ANTI-GAY
RHETORIC CREATES CLIMATE CONDUCIVE TO VIOLENCE
President Clinton Issues
Statement Asking The Nation To Pray For Shepard Family And Urges America
To Stand Together Against Violent Bigotry
WASHINGTON -- HRC Education Director Kim I. Mills condemned
the violent attack against Matthew Shepard and called for Congress to
renew their efforts to pass national hate crimes legislation at a press
conference today in Ft. Collins, Colorado. The recent anti-gay
political rhetoric by right wing organizations and members of Congress
have created a climate where hate crimes are more likely to occur,
according to the Human Rights Campaign.
"The savage beating and
burning of Matthew Shepard did not occur in a vacuum. Crimes such as
these arise out of minds twisted and misinformed about lesbian and gay
people. The leaders of the most powerful religious political
organizations -- some of which have headquarters right here in Colorado --
have made a strategic, political decision to target gays and
lesbians," said Mills at the press conference.
President Clinton called the
Shepard family today and released a statement denouncing the attack.
The Clinton administration has helped lead the on-going effort to pass
federal hate crimes legislation.
"I was deeply grieved by
the act of violence perpetuated against Matthew Shepard. There is
nothing more important to the future of this country than our standing
together against intolerance, prejudice, and violent bigotry.
It is not too late for Congress to take action before they adjourn and
pass the Hate Crimes Prevention Act. By doing so, they will help
make all Americans more safe and secure," said President Clinton in
his statement.
Two men, Russell Arthur
Henderson, 21, and Aaron James McKinney, whose age is unconfirmed, were
charged with kidnaping aggravated robbery, and attempted first degree
murder and held on $100,000 bond. University of Wyoming student,
Chastity Vera Pasley, 20 and Kristen Leann Price, 18, were charged
as accessories to the crime. Price was released on $30,000 bond and
Pasely is still in jail in lieu of the same amount of money.
There are no hate crimes laws
in Wyoming and efforts to pass a law have been rebuffed repeatedly because
critics have claimed it would give gay Americans "special
rights."
"There is nothing special
about living life free of violence and nothing right about opposing laws
that would help remedy this situation. Those who oppose hate crimes
legislation are either burying their heads in the sand or they simply
don't care that thousands of gay and lesbian Americans are being harassed
and brutalized each year," said HRC Executive Director Elizabeth
Birch.
On Thursday night,
Matthew Shepard, a gay University of Wyoming student, was savagely
attacked, burned, and left to die for up to 18 hours tied to a wooden
fence outside Laramie, 30 miles northwest of Cheyenne. When Shepard
was found he was unconscious and his skull had been smashed with a blunt
object; he also appeared to have substantial burns on his body and cuts on
his head and face, his family said. Two motorcyclists who found his
body said he looked "like a scarecrow" because of the way he was
positioned on the fence. Shepard is now in critical condition in the
intensive care unit at Poudre Valley Hospital in Fort Collins, Colorado
where he remains unconscious and hooked up to a respirator. He had
twice been beaten recently and attributed those attacks to his openness
about his sexuality, friends told the Associated Press. Shepard's
family is now with him at the hospital.
In July, both the House and
Senate Judiciary Committees held hearings to amend current federal law to
include sexual orientation, gender and disability and to expand federal
law enforcement jurisdiction is an important step towards closing a
loophole needed to assist Americans affected by hate motivated attacks.
But since the hearings, there has been no movement on this legislation.
The Hate Crimes Prevention Act (HCPA), sponsored by Senators Kennedy
(D-MA), Specter (R-PA), and Wyden (D-OR), and Representatives McCollum
(R-FL) and Schumer (D-NY), would amend current federal law to include real
or perceived sexual orientation, gender, and disability. The
amendment would enable the FBI to investigate and prosecute violent hate
crimes against gays, lesbians, and bisexuals. Current law already
allows investigation and prosecution only on the basis of race, religion,
national origin and color.
A study released in August by
Dr. Karen Franklin, a forensic psychologist at the Washington Institute
for Mental Illness Research and Training, suggests that harassment and
hate crimes against gay students by their peers is commonplace.
According to the study, nearly one-quarter of community college students
who took part in this survey admitted to harassing people they thought
were gay. Among men, 18 percent said they had physically assaulted
or threatened someone they thought was gay or lesbian. And 32
percent admitted they were guilty of verbal harassment.
Hate
crimes committed against gays, lesbians, and bisexuals make up the
third-highest category of hate crimes reported to the FBI, currently
representing 11.6% of all hate crimes reported. Only 21 states and
the District of Columbia include sexual orientation-based crimes in their
hate crimes statutes. While states continue to play the primary role in
the prosecution of hate violence, the federal government must have
jurisdiction to address those limited cases in which local authorities are
either unable or unwilling to investigate and prosecute.
The Human Rights Campaign is
the nation's largest national lesbian and gay political organization, with
members throughout the country, effectively lobbies Congress, provides
campaign support, and educates the public to ensure that lesbian and gay
Americans can be open, honest, and safe at home, at work, and in the
community.
Statement of Kim I. Mills
Education Director, Human Rights Campaign Oct. 10, 1998
The savage beating and burning of Matthew Shepard
did not occur in a vacuum. Crimes such as these arise out of minds twisted
and misinformed about lesbian and gay people.
Crimes such as these are not isolated --
unfortunately. At the Human Rights Campaign~ we learn weekly, if not
daily, of terrible acts committed against our fellow citizens merely
because they are gay -or even because they are perceived to be gay or
lesbian.
Right now, we are living through a period of
extreme and concentrated anti-gay backlash. The leaders of the most
powerful religious political organizations -- some of which have
headquarters right here in Colorado -- have made a strategic political
decision to target gays and lesbians. These groups include Focus on
the Family and its political offshoot, the Family Research Council; the
Christian Coalition; Coral Ridge Ministries; and a host of others.
Make no mistake; this campaign against gay people
is not about religion or redemption or any of those other
"spiritual" terms they might use in their advertising or public
relations. They are looking for wedge issues that will help them elect
more staunch religious political conservatives at all levels of
government. If this were truly a religious campaign, why did these men and
women go to Capitol Hill last spring and meet with the Republican leaders
of the House and Senate? Why did they threaten our national leaders with a
loss of support if they refused to follow the ultra-conservative religious
political agenda?
And they were successful. Shortly after their
meeting on Capitol Hill, Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott went on
television to say gay people are sinners and that we are sick. He likened
us to alcoholics, sex addicts and kleptomaniacs.
Just this week, in Washington, D.C., these same
religious political activist groups unveiled a television advertising
campaign purporting to offer people a way out of homosexuality"
through prayer. This comes on the heels of a national newspaper print
advertising campaign with the same message. They have already spent half a
million dollars. We should all fear to learn how much more they are
willing to spend because -- as you in Colorado well know -- their pockets
are deep.
The results of campaigns like this are
terrifying. The ultimate victims of their message are people like Matthew
Shepard people who happen to step into the paths of individuals who
are swayed by the messages of such ads and by the climate of intolerance
that they are fostering. Wearing the cloak of "Christian
charity," these ads proclaim that lesbians and gays are defective,
that being gay is a bad thing that we can and should change.
Because these messengers are wolves in
"Christian" clothing, some of the people hearing these messages
doubtless believe they are being given a "biblical" dispensation
to despise gays and lesbians. And the distance between that kind of hatred
and overt violence is far too short. Ask the thousands of people who are
the targets every year of anti-gay hate crimes. I would tell you to ask
Matthew Shepard, but you cannot.
So why did I come all the way from Washington to
talk to people in Colorado today? Because the terrible news of what
happened to Matthew Shepard is sweeping through a horrified gay community,
a gay community already beleaguered by this period of backlash. I am here
to say, "Enough." And I am here to say we need a federal law to
help protect all Americans from hate crimes based on sexual orientation--
real or perceived.
There is no hate crimes law in Wyoming. And while
I hope the people who tried to kill Matthew Shepard are punished to the
full extent of the law, the law in this case is insufficient. Not only can
they not face additional punishment because this was, in my view, a hate
crime, they also face no federal penalty -- unlike people who commit hate
crimes based on race,religion, national origin or disability.
Hate crimes based on sexual orientation are the
third-highest category of all hate crimes reported to the FBI -- holding
steady around 11 percent a year.
There is a bill in Congress now called the Hate
Crimes Prevention Act. It would give the federal government the power to
investigate crimes such as the one committed against Matthew Shepard.Until
and unless that passes, they cannot intervene. We need this law.
Finally, let me close by noting that tomorrow is
National Coming Out Day -- the day when the Human Rights Campaign urges
all lesbian and gay people to be open about ourselves and here is
the terrifying story of a young man who tried to live an openly gay life,
only to suffer the most horrific of consequences. Matthew Shepard tried to
live that example, and now he has become an example of how dangerous it
still is to be a lesbian or gay person in America at the turn of this
century. I hope and pray that this example will not drive gay people back
into the shadows -- where the religious right would prefer we live.
Rather, he should become a clarion call to every fair-minded person
in this nation to stop this climate of hate, to stamp out anti-gay bigotry
wherever they see it.
Thank you.
Sat Oct 10, 1998 - 3:26PM EDT
- PRESIDENT CLINTON ISSUES STATEMENT
"I was deeply grieved by the act of violence perpetrated against
Matthew Shepard of Wyoming.
The Justice Department has
assured me that local law enforcement officials are proceeding diligently
to bring those responsible to justice. And I am determined that we will do
everything we can and offer whatever assistance is appropriate.
Hillary and I ask that your
thoughts and your prayers be with Mr. Shepard and his family, and
with the people of Laramie, Wyoming. In the face of this terrible
act of violence, they are joining together to demonstrate that an act of
evil like this is not what our country is all about. In fact it
strikes at the very heart of what it means to be an American and at the
values that define us as a Nation. We must all reaffirm that we will not
tolerate this.
Just this year there have been a
number of recent tragedies across our country that involve hate crimes.
The vicious murder of James Byrd last June in Jasper, Texas and the
assault this week on Mr. Shepard are only among the most horrifying
examples. Almost one year ago I proposed that Congress enact the
Hate Crimes Prevention Act. Our Federal laws already punish some crimes
committed against people on the basis of race or religion or national
origin, but we should do more. This crucial legislation would
strengthen and expand the ability of the Justice Department to prosecute
hate crimes by removing needless jurisdictional requirements for existing
crimes and by giving Federal prosecutors the power to prosecute hate
crimes committed because of the victim's sexual orientation, gender, or
disability. All Americans deserve protection from hate.
There is nothing more important
to the future of this country than our standing together against
intolerance, prejudice, and violent bigotry. It is not too late for
Congress to take action before they adjourn and pass The Hate Crimes
Prevention Act. By doing so they will help make all Americans more
safe and secure."
Sat Oct 10, 1998 - 3:15PM EDT
- HOUSE DEM. LEADER GEPHARDT ISSUES STATEMENT
"My thoughts and prayers today are with Matthew Shepard and his
family. I was sickened to learn of the brutal attack Matthew
suffered -- an attack at the hands of people whose apparent motive was
that he is a gay man.
This heinous crime deserves the
condemnation of all Americans. Hate crimes such as this and the June
murder of James Byrd in Texas are violent acts motivated by intolerance
and hatred. I trust that those responsible for this horrendous
attack will be prosecuted and punished to the full extent of the law and
firmly believe that we must pass the tough hate crimes legislation pending
in the Congress to help stop these despicable acts."
Sat Oct 10, 1998 - 12:43PM EDT
- LOTS OF ARTICLES IN DENVER POST
Today's Denver Post has a slew of articles on the Shepard attack - best to
visit the site and read the
articles first hand.
I include one story that is so
good, I had to reprint it:
Gay bashing is a hate crime
By Diane Carman, Denver Post Staff Columnist
Arthur Dong is a gay man who has
experienced more than one beating at the hands of homophobic psychopaths.
In 1996, he decided to fight back. Video camera in hand, Dong entered the
belly of the beast.
What he found was even more horrible than he
imagined.
Dong won an award at the Sundance Film Festival
for his 1997 documentary, "Licensed to Kill,'' which features a
series of prison interviews with seven men convicted of murdering gay men.
The movie, which screened in Denver last year,
allows the murderers to tell their own stories. Some of them had come to
realize the severity of their crimes. Some remained unrepentant. Some even
recalled their crimes with pride.
But in many ways the most revealing aspect of the
film is that it illustrates how a culture that ridicules, dehumanizes and
demonizes homosexuals bears shameful responsibility for these crimes.
The verbal taunts and persecution of people
because of their sexual orientation are so commonplace they set the stage
for murderers who think it's no crime to hate gays and to act on that
hate.
In our culture, the victim of gay bashing is
considered the sinner. That's why so often the crimes against homosexuals
go unpunished until someone is found beaten, burned and tied to a fence
post outside of town.
The attack this week on Matthew Shepard, the
21-year-old gay University of Wyoming student, is unusual only in its
level of savagery. Since hate crimes laws in Colorado and 28 other states
do not cover crimes against homosexuals, vast numbers of these crimes go
unreported. Still, FBI data indicate that 11.6 percent of all hate crimes
nationally target gays. It's the third largest category of hate crimes
reported to the bureau.
In June, when the story of the vicious racially
inspired murder of James Byrd Jr. of Jasper, Texas, was reported, it
horrified Americans. Attorney General Janet Reno called for an
investigation to see if federal civil rights laws had been violated. The
U.S. House of Representatives voted unanimously to send "heartfelt
condolences'' to Byrd's family.
There was no argument about what constitutes a
hate crime, only collective shame and grief.
That same level of compassion does not exist for
the Shepard family. Once again, there will be a chorus screaming
"special rights'' when the subject of gay bashing being punished as a
hate crime arises. But near as anybody can tell, the opportunity to be
threatened, humiliated and to live in fear of being beaten to death is the
only "special right'' our culture bestows on homosexuals.
If you listened to the opponents of laws
designating gay bashing as a hate crime, you'd think there really was some
fundamental difference between being a black man, who is beaten and
dragged behind a truck, and being a gay man, who is beaten, his skull
crushed, and left tied to a fence to die.
The only real difference is the epithet the
killers use to describe the victim.
The one used for the black man is considered an
obscenity so appallingly offensive, it can't be printed in most
newspapers.
The one used for the gay man is a common
expression. It's familiar in comedy routines, on elementary school
playgrounds and on street corners all across America.
Diane Carman's commentaries appear here Tuesday,
Thursday and Saturday.
E-mail: dicarman@aol.com
Sat Oct 10, 1998 - NEW YORK
TIMES ON SHEPARD CASE
Nothing really new in this piece from the New
York Times.
Sat Oct 10, 1998 - 7:12AM EDT
- SHEPARD'S CONDITION UPDATES ONLINE
Matthew Shepard Condition Update
Poudre Valley Health System
Fort Collins, Colorado
http://www.pvhs.org/new/index.html
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
October 7, 1998
Matthew Shepard, 21, was transported to Poudre Valley Hospital from
Invinson Hospital in Laramie, Wyoming. He arrived on 10/7/98 at
approximately 9:15 p.m.. When he arrived he was unresponsive and breathing
support was being provided. Matthew Shepard was admitted to the surgical-neuro
intensive care unit at Poudre Valley Hospital.
October 8, 1998 Noon
Matthew Shepard remains in critical condition with severe head injuries.
Respiratory support continues to be provided. He remains on a ventilator.
The family requests no interviews
with the media, and asks that you respect their privacy.
Calls have come into the hospital from people who have extended offers of
donations and support. The hospital will pass this information on to the
family. The support is greatly appreciated.
The next medical update will be at 3 p.m. in the circle drive on the west
side of the hospital.
October 9 -- 3 p.m. Update
There is no status change. The next medical condition update will be
posted to the web site at 9 p.m. tonight and simultaneously on the voice
mail listed below. This website will be updated immediately if the
patient's condition changes. We will also immediately inform the wire
services.
October 9 -- 9 p.m. Update
This medical update is given by Rulon Stacey, President/CEO of Poudre
Valley Hospital.
There is no change in Matthew Shepard’s status since our 3 p.m. update
today.
Matthew came to us from Ivinson
Hospital in Laramie by way of ambulance. He arrived on 10/7/98 at
approximately 9:15 p.m.. When he arrived, he was unresponsive and
breathing support was being provided. He was admitted to the
surgical-neuro intensive care unit where he remains in critical condition
with severe head injuries. Respiratory support continues to be provided.
He remains on a ventilator. Matthew’s parents arrived this evening
and are now at his bed side. The parents and other family members who are
present strongly request no interviews with the media and they ask that
their privacy is respected.
About a dozen calls have come
into the hospital from people in Colorado and around the nation who have
extended offers of donations and support. The parents extend their
very sincere thank you for this support and the kind best wishes of
people. The parents ask that in lieu of sending flowers people contribute
to a fund that was set up today in Matthew’s name. Donations can be sent
to:
Fund for the Benefit of Matthew
Shepard
c/o First National Bank
P.O. Box 578
Fort Collins, CO 80522
Account No. 1926083
The next medical condition update
will be at 9 a.m. Saturday. In addition, updates will be kept current
throughout tonight and posted on this web site. The condition is also
provided on voice mail: (970) 495-7032. We ask that people, including the
media, rely on these two services if you need to track Matthew’s
condition throughout the night.
Note: A special voice mail
telephone line has been set-up for condition updates. The voice mail will
provide the same information listed here. The number is (970) 495-7032.
Sat Oct 10, 1998 - SHEPARD
BEGGED FOR HIS LIFE
New in this Associated Press story:
* The two men who beat and tortured a gay University of Wyoming student
ignored his pleas that they spare his life, leaving him tied to a ranch
fence, unconscious and barely breathing, investigators said Friday.
"During the incident the victim was begging for his life," said
Albany
County Judge Robert A. Castor, reading an arrest affadavit.
* Shepard's family and friends hoped the brutal attack on Shepard would
galvanize the state into passing a hate crime law.
* "It seems pretty obvious from the court proceedings that he
was beaten and robbed because he was gay," said Terry Summers, a
friend who is the executive director of the Fort Collins-based gay support
group LAMBDA. "It's sad to say, that Wyoming has no hate crime
laws."
* Officials said Shepard was pistol-whipped with a .357 Magnum, which was
later
recovered.
* Several national gay and lesbian groups denounced the attack and said
Wyoming's failure to adopt a law against hate crimes may have led the
perpetrators to believe such acts might not be aggressively prosecuted.
They also said a national campaign by conservative religious organizations
targeting gays has made their lives more precarious.
* Wyoming Gov. Jim Geringer said, "I am outraged and sickened by what
appears to be a very heinous crime committed on Matthew Shepard."
Geringer said "hate crime legislation is needed ...." as well as
tougher sentences for violent offenders.
Sat Oct 10, 1998 - 2:40AM EDT
- NGLTF ISSUES STATEMENT
NATIONAL GAY AND LESBIAN TASK FORCE PRESS RELEASE
Contact:
Tracey Conaty, Communications Director
202-332-6483 ext. 3303
800-757-6476 pager
tconaty@ngltf.org
http://www.ngltf.org
2320 17th Street NW, Washington, DC 20009
***********************************************
TASK FORCE CONDEMNS SAVAGE
BASHING;
CHARGES RIGHT WING WITH INCREASE IN ANTI-GAY RHETORIC
WASHINGTON, DC---October 9,
1998--- The National Gay and Lesbian Task Force condemned Tuesday¹s gay
bashing in Laramie, Wyoming where a student was severely burned, beaten,
and left to die. The Task Force linked the violence to an increased
climate of anti-gay hostility and political attacks in nearby Fort
Collins, the Wyoming legislature, and in the US Congress.
"Anti-gay rhetoric and
anti-gay violence go hand-in-hand," said Tracey Conaty, NGLTF
communications director. "The right wing is creating the most hostile
atmospheres for GLBT people in recent memory. Hate violence is a
logical extension of these rhetorical, legislative, and electoral attacks,
" she added.
Matthew Shepard, a 22-year-old
political science student at the University of Wyoming, was found tied to
a fence the day after having been left to die by his assailants. He had
burns on his entire body and had been beaten so severely with a blunt
object that his skull was crushed. He is on a respirator at a nearby
hospital in Fort Collins, CO. Shepard had been beaten recently and
attributed the attack to his sexual orientation. In that attack, he
suffered a broken jaw.
The Task Force charges that right
wing groups have fostered a climate conducive to such violence. This week
in Fort Collins, Citizens for Constitutional Freedom, a right-wing
opposition group ran a series of ads denouncing the measures and urging
voters not to support "special rights" for homosexuals. A
similar organization sponsored a forum with an "ex-gay"
Spokesperson, which claimed sexual orientation can be changed, and
therefore does not deserve inclusion in Fort Collins¹ Human Rights
Ordinance.
Right wing forces in Wyoming have
stymied passage of a hate crimes bill claiming it would give "special
rights" to GLBT people. Nationally, right-wing organizations have
hypocritically portrayed their anti-gay efforts as "compassionate and
loving." In June, Senate majority leader Trent Lott compared
homosexuality to kleptomania and sex addiction. Recent anti-gay measures
in Congress were introduced while right-wing groups launched a major
advertising campaign to "change" GLBT people. Just
yesterday, these groups announced a series of TV ads seeking to
"reject homosexuality and go on to live healthy normal lives."
The Task Force has documented a
link between increases in anti-gay violence and the escalation of anti-gay
rhetoric during ballot initiative campaigns. Immediately before Colorado¹s
Amendment 2 passed in 1992, Colorado activists documented a 129 percent
increase in anti-gay assaults. In the two months following the vote,
nearly 40 percent of the annual total was reported. Hattie Mae Cohen, a
lesbian, and Brian Mock, a gay man, were killed when their home in Oregon
was firebombed during that state¹s 1992 ballot battle. In Maine in 1995,
incidents of anti-gay violence jumped to 10 during the six months of an
anti-gay initiative campaign in 1995, compared to four incidents for the
entire previous year.
"When anti-gay rhetoric
escalates, so does anti-gay violence. Hate crimes are a result of that
intolerance," continued Conaty. "No one should condone violence
against any group of people, nor should they contribute to an atmosphere
that fosters such intolerance and violence."
A bill languishing in Congress,
the Hate Crimes Prevention Act, would make hate violence against gay,
lesbian, bisexual, and transgender people and other minorities a federal
crime. The Task Force urges Congress to swiftly pass this measure.
________________________________________
Founded in 1973, the National Gay
and Lesbian Task Force works to eliminate prejudice, violence and
injustice against gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgendered people at the
local, state and national level. As part of a broader social justice
movement for freedom, justice and equality, NGLTF is creating a world that
respects and celebrates the diversity of human expression and identity
where all people may fully participate in society.
Sat Oct 10, 1998 - 2:39AM EDT
- GLAAD ISSUES STATEMENT
GLAAD MEDIA RELEASE
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact:
Jennifer Einhorn, Director of Communications
phone: (212) 807-1700 x14
e-mail: einhorn@glaad.org
pager: (888) 656-9045
Jeffrey Montgomery, NCAVP
Steering Committee
phone: (313) 537-3323
e-mail: trijeffm@aol.com
GLAAD AND NATIONAL COALITION OF
ANTI-VIOLENCE PROGRAMS EXPRESS SORROW AND HORROR AT ATTACK ON GAY MAN IN
WYOMING
_______________________________________________________________
"Hateful rhetoric
fosters a fearful and intolerant environment--all the ingredients
necessary for putting people in harms way. What Matt Shepard is going
through is unthinkable. That there are people who hate him for being
open and honest about his life is unconscionable."
-Joan M. Garry, GLAAD Executive
Director
_______________________________________________________________
NEW YORK, NY, THURSDAY, 9
OCTOBER, 1998 -- The Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation (GLAAD)
and the National Coalition of Anti-Violence Programs (NCAVP) today
expressed their sorrow at the attempted murder of 22-year-old University
of Wyoming student Matt Shepard, who was found on Wednesday night in
Laramie near death and tied to a fence, after having been beaten, burned
and slashed. Mr. Shepard, a junior studying political science at the
university, had been attacked twice previously in recent weeks, once
having his jaw broken.
The report of the Wyoming attack
comes one day after the Center for Reclaiming America and Coral Ridge
Ministries held a joint press conference with the Family Research Council
to announce a new series of anti-gay television advertisements, in the
same vein as their previous campaign, which was placed in major newspapers
this summer.
The National Coalition of
Anti-Violence Programs condemned the attack as well. "We at NCAVP are
all too familiar with the increasing violence facing the lesbian, gay
bisexual and transgender community, and the increasingly vicious nature of
these crimes," said NCAVP Steering Committee member Jeffrey
Montgomery. "What happened to Matt Shepard may shock and horrify you,
but something like it happens on a day to day basis in this country.
What's worse, Wyoming has no hate crimes bill to protect victims and
prosecute those who target them, because radical religious groups insisted
it would extend 'special rights' to lesbians and gay men, who have become
less than equal in their eyes. Is it a 'special right' to not be beaten
into a coma because of who you are? Ask the victims of the thousands of
anti-gay hate crimes...they're the ones who know."
GLAAD Executive Director, Joan M.
Garry continued, "We invite those who are so obsessed with the lives
of lesbians and gay men to examine the tone and tenor of their remarks
well before they issue them. Think of who will hear their words. Think of
who will see these indelible images. If you think homophobic
advertisements like those which ran in our newspapers this summer are
devoid of repercussions--think again. These ads give people
permission to hate. They are inciteful vehicles. They have a real
impact on real people's lives."
GLAAD is the nation's lesbian and
gay media advocacy organization. GLAAD promotes fair, accurate and
inclusive representation of individuals and events in all media as a means
of combating homophobia and all forms of discrimination based on sexual
orientation or identity.
The National Coalition of
Anti-Violence Programs (NCAVP) addresses the pervasive problem of violence
committed against and within the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and
HIV-positive (LGBTH) communities. NCAVP is a coalition of programs that
document and advocate for victims of anti-LGBTH violence/harassment,
domestic violence, sexual assault, police Misconduct, and other forms of
victimization. NCAVP is dedicated to creating a national response to the
violence plaguing these communities. Furthermore, NCAVP supports existing
anti-violence organizations and emerging local programs in the efforts to
document and prevent such violence.
Sat Oct 10, 1998 - 2:38AM EDT
- ANTI-GAY HATE SPEECH AT MICHIGAN STATE
On Wednesday, the Alliance of Lesbian-Bi-Gay and Transgendered Students
painted the rock [a local landmark] in honor of National Coming Out Days,
a celebration of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgendered people. They
woke Thursday morning to see the the rock had been repainted with anti-gay
slurs. The front of the rock read “no packing zone.” Other slurs on
the rock and garbage can next to it read “I kill fags,” “Kill
flames,” and “Fags.”
Sat Oct 10, 1998 - 1:29 AM EDT
- SUMMARY OF NEWS STORIES TO DATE
WIRED STRATEGIES
Special Report: Gay Wyoming student clings to life
Saturday, October 10, 1998
1:30 a.m. EDT
The University of Wyoming student
paper, the Branding Iron, has published on its Web
site a series of nine stories, and numerous photos, dealing with the
attack on Matthew Shepard. In addition the Washington
Post Web site published a front page story on the case at midnight.
And a new Associated Press story was issued at 9:37PM EDT, Oct 9.
Details from all 11 stories have been compiled in the following brief
update.
A Brief Update - Summary of
Recent Branding Iron, Washington Post, and Associated Press Articles
At last report, Matthew Shepard
remained in a coma, in critical condition, in Colorado - according to the
hospital, he is on a ventilator. "They're not expecting him to
ever wake up," friends say. His parents are to arrive
this evening from Saudi Arabia.
His four accused attackers (two
men), and accomplices (two women), were arraigned Friday in court, and
remain in police custody. According to reports, the two males
befriended Shepard in a bar, told him they were gay, and lured him into
their pick-up truck. Shepard was subsequently attacked in the truck,
then dragged to a field where he was tied to a fence post spread-eagle,
beaten and burned, then left to die. According to court documents,
Shepard was "struck in the head with a pistol," and the suspects
allegedly "beat him, while he begged for his life."
According to one report, Shepard received a 2-inch deep gash in his head,
crushing his skull. The temperature had dropped into the low 30s
during the more than 12 hours Shepard was left outside. The males
then met up with the two female accomplices, who helped them dispose of
their now-bloody clothing.
Anti-gay epithets were reportedly
used by the two young men who are accused of committing the crime, and
friends say the attack was clearly an anti-gay hate crime. Efforts
to pass hate-crime legislation in Wyoming have failed repeatedly because
critics have said it would give gays "special rights." The
conservative Family Research Council (FRC) -- which joined other religious
right groups in announcing on Thursday a new round of anti-gay
"ex-homosexual" TV ads -- released a statement Friday on
Shepard's attack, echoing the arguments of previous hate crimes opponents.
FRC said in their statement that "'Hate crimes' laws skew the legal
system and afford unequal protection by design" and that such laws
create a "special status." In contrast, Wyoming's
Republican Governor, Jim Geringer, said he was "outraged and
sickened" by the crime, and that the state needs to enact hate crime
legislation.
"He's a small person with a
big heart, mind and soul that someone tried to beat out of him," said
Matthew Shepard's uncle, R.W. Eaton. "Right now, he's in God's
hands."
Fri Oct 9, 1998 - 9:18PM EDT -
SEND A CARD TO MATTHEW
Courtesy of the Fenceberrys:
If you would like to send a card to Matthew Shepard and wish him a full
and speedy recovery after his terrible ordeal, you can mail it to:
Matthew Shepard
C/O Poudre Valley Hospital
1024 S Lemay Av FORT COLLINS CO 80524
The phone number for the hospital is (970) 495-7000
Fri Oct 9, 1998 - 6:10PM EDT -
FAMILY RESEARCH COUNCIL OPPOSES HATE CRIME LAWS
WASHINGTON, Oct. 9 /PRNewswire/ -- Family Research Council today denounced
an attack on a homosexual student in Wyoming. "Although the
motivation for the attack is not confirmed at this time, violently
attacking a person is unconscionable, whatever the reason," said
Robert H. Knight, Director of Cultural Studies at Family Research Council.
"It is indicative of a culture that has become inured to violence and
has lost respect for the human person."
The Associated Press reported
that Matthew Shepard, a 22-year-old political science major at the
University of Wyoming, was bludgeoned in the head with a "blunt
object," burned and tied to a wooden fence outside the city of
Laramie.
"Whoever committed this
crime should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law," said
Knight, who cautioned that some are already exploiting this tragedy to
advance the cause of so-called "hate crimes" legislation, which
creates attitudinal crimes and a special status for certain victims.
"Every crime is a 'hate' crime. Brutalizing a person is a
reprehensible act, regardless of the motivation or the group affiliation
of the victim.
"All citizens deserve equal
protection under the law. 'Hate crimes' laws skew the legal system
and afford unequal protection by design. This young man, no less
than anyone else, should be protected, and his attackers should feel the
full force of the law," stressed Knight. "The law should
deal strictly with facts and acts. Justice dictates that violence be
punished, and that the perpetrators be held fully accountable,"
Knight concluded."
Fri Oct 9, 1998 - 5:41PM EDT -
WYOMING NICKNAME IS "EQUALITY STATE"
Ironically, the Wyoming state motto is: "Equal Rights", and the
official state nickname is "the Equality State". You can
confirm this at: <http://www.state.wy.us/state/wyoming_news/general/general.html>.
Fri Oct 9, 1998 - 5:15PM EDT -
SHEPARD'S SKULL SMASHED WITH HANDGUN
New in this story from the Associated Press:
* When he was found, Shepard was unconscious, and his skull had been
smashed with a handgun.
Fri Oct 9, 1998 - 3:45PM EDT -
SHEPARD CHOSEN IN PART BECAUSE HE WAS GAY
New in this story from the Associated Press:
* Police Cmdr. Dave O'Malley said that robbery was the chief motive but
that the victim was chosen in part because he is gay.
* The temperature had dropped into the low 30s during the more than 12
hours Shepard was left outside.
* O'Malley, a 25-year veteran of the police force, said there had been a
few hate crimes over the years, ``but nothing anywhere near this.''
Fri Oct 9, 1998 - 3:45PM EDT -
SCHOOL PAPER ADDS DETAILS
New in this story from the University of Wyoming paper, the "Branding
Iron":
* Shepard, who suffered severe head trauma, was unconscious upon discovery
and was still unconscious at press time.
* "They're not expecting him to ever wake up," Walter Boulden, a
friend of the victim, said.
* An alleged aggravated assault which occurred approximately at 1 a.m.
Oct. 7 in the vicinity of 7th and Harney led officers to the suspects,
Puls said.
Fri Oct 9, 1998 - 2:28PM EDT -
FRIENDS SAY CLEARLY A HATE CRIME
New in this story from the Associated Press:
* Walter Boulden, a friend of the victim's, said he believes the crime was
clearly motivated by hate. ``There is no maybe,'' he told the Branding
Iron, the campus paper.
* `It's really hard to be gay and live in Wyoming because of the good-ol'-boy
network,'' said another student, Kete Blonigen.
* ``It's such a conservative state,'' said Kete Blonigen, a local student.
``I'm almost afraid and expecting someone to say, `He was gay. What does
it matter?' I can totally see that happening. I'm disgusted by this whole
thing.''
Fri Oct 9, 1998 - 1:03PM EDT -
LOCAL OFFICIALS SAY ROBBERY WAS MOTIVE, BUT SEXUAL ORIENTATION PLAYED A
ROLE
Nando Times published a story, based in part on an Associated Press
report, that robberty appears to be the motive behind the savage attack on
Matthew Shepard. New information in this story:
* A University of Wyoming student and three other people were arrested
Thursday in connection with the beating and were scheduled to be in court
Friday. A new name was added to the arrestees, Aaron McKinney -- ,
whose age was not immediately available, and who was expected to be
charged with attempted first-degree murder, kidnapping and robbery.
* Shepard apparently drove off in McKinney's truck with the two men. The
two beat Shepard in
the truck, then continued to beat him after tying him up to the fence
outside Laramie. They took his wallet and shoes and left him. Later,
the two young women helped them get rid of their bloody clothing.
* The two men made anti-gay statements to the two women, who told police
about them.
* The Denver Post reports that one local resident "wasn't shocked to
hear a gay man had been beaten so
severely." She said: "Here in the rural West, such
intolerance still is not that unusual."
Fri Oct 9, 1998 - 10:26AM EDT
- HUMAN RIGHTS CAMPAIGN ISSUES STATEMENT
"APPARENT HATE CRIME AGAINST GAY STUDENT IN WYOMING HIGHLIGHTS THE
NEED FOR CONGRESS TO PASS THE HATE CRIMES PREVENTION ACT
Brutality Continues While
Congress Lets Bill Languish, According To HRC
WASHINGTON -- A gay University of Wyoming student was savagely attacked
Thursday night, burned, and left to die for up to 18 hours tied to a
wooden fence outside Laramie, 30 miles northwest of Cheyenne. The
assault on Matthew Shepard, 21, by fellow students underscores the need
for Congress to move forward and pass pending hate crimes legislation,
according HRC.
"We are outraged and sickened by this attack performed by a group of
cowards. How long does the brutality have to go on until Congress
sends the message that this type of behavior is unacceptable and will not
be tolerated in our society? It is time to pass the Hate Crimes
Prevention Act," said HRC Political Director Winnie Stachelberg.
When Shepard was found he was unconscious and his skull had been smashed
with a blunt object; he also appeared to have substantial burns on his
body and cuts on his head and face, his family said. Two
motorcyclists who found his body said he looked "like a
scarecrow" because of the way he was positioned on the fence.
Shepard is now in critical condition in the intensive care unit at Poudre
Valley Hospital in Fort Collins, Colorado where he remains unconscious and
hooked up to a respirator. He had twice been beaten recently and
attributed those attacks to his openness about his sexuality, friends told
the Associated Press.
Three University of Wyoming students were arrested Thursday in connection
with the attack. Authorities say they expect more arrests.
There are no hate crimes laws in Wyoming and efforts to pass a law have
been rebuffed repeatedly because critics have claimed it would give gay
Americans "special rights."
"There is nothing special about living life free of violence and
nothing right about opposing laws that would help remedy this situation.
Those who oppose hate crimes legislation are either burying their heads in
the sand or they simply don't care that thousands of gay and lesbian
Americans are being harassed and brutalized each year," said HRC
Executive Director Elizabeth Birch.
In July, both the House and Senate Judiciary Committees held hearings to
amend current federal law to include sexual orientation, gender and
disability and to expand federal law enforcement jurisdiction is an
important step towards closing a loophole needed to assist Americans
affected by hate motivated attacks. But since the hearings, there has been
no movement on this legislation. The Hate Crimes Prevention Act (HCPA),
sponsored by Senators Kennedy (D-MA), Specter (R-PA), and Wyden (D-OR),
and Representatives McCollum (R-FL) and Schumer (D-NY), would amend
current federal law to include real or perceived sexual orientation,
gender, and disability. The amendment would enable the FBI to
investigate
and prosecute violent hate crimes against gays, lesbians, and bisexuals.
Current law already allows investigation and prosecution only on the basis
of race, religion, national origin and color.
A study released in August by Dr. Karen Franklin, a forensic psychologist
at the Washington Institute for Mental Illness Research and Training,
suggests that harassment and hate crimes against gay students by their
peers is commonplace. According to the study, nearly one-quarter of
community college students who took part in this survey admitted to
harassing people they thought were gay. Among men, 18 percent said
they had physically assaulted or threatened someone they thought was gay
or lesbian. And 32 percent admitted they were guilty of verbal
harassment.
Hate crimes committed against
gays, lesbians, and bisexuals make up the third-highest category of hate
crimes reported to the FBI, currently representing 11.6% of all hate
crimes reported. Only 21 states and the District of Columbia include
sexual orientation-based crimes in their hate crimes statutes. While
states continue to play the primary role in the prosecution of hate
violence, the federal government must have
jurisdiction to address those limited cases in which local authorities are
either unable or unwilling to investigate and prosecute.
The Human Rights Campaign is the nation's largest national lesbian and gay
political organization, with members throughout the country, effectively
lobbies Congress, provides campaign support, and educates the public to
ensure that lesbian and gay Americans can be open, honest, and safe at
home, at work, and in the community.
Fri Oct 9, 1998 - 10:25AM EDT
- DENVER POST REPORTS ON SHEPARD ATTACK
New details revealed in this story:
* Shepard dedicated his life to the fight for human rights.
* He remained tied up to the wooden fence for 18 hours before he was
found.
* Shepard almost died of blood loss before passers-by discovered him.
* Shepard had been beaten up twice in the recent past - his jaw was broken
last summer - and he attributed those attacks to his open homosexuality,
friends said.
* "He's a small person with a big heart, mind and soul that someone
tried to beat out of him,'' Eaton [his uncle] said. "Right now, he's
in God's hands.''
* His aunt and uncle described Shepard's appearance as horrifying, with
wounds concentrated on his head and face. The most severe blow was
inflicted with a weapon akin to a rifle butt or baseball bat and probably
caused irreparable brain damage, Eaton said. "He looks like
hell,'' Rose said. "I can't explain it. I don't know how to explain
it. He is hanging onto life by a thread.'' Said Eaton: "It's
like something you might see in war.''
* The trio awaiting arraignment today are: Russel Arthur Henderson, 21, of
3443 Fort Sanders Drive, arrested for investigation of attempted
first-degree murder; Chastity Vera Pasley, 20, of the same address,
arrested for investigation as an accessory to the crime; Kristin Leann
Price, 18, of 751 N. Fourth St., arrested for investigation as an
accessory.
* Shepard spent some of his time growing up in Casper. His father and
mother, Dennis and Judy Shepard, live in Saudi Arabia, where the elder
Shepard works as an oil rig safety inspector. The parents were en
route to Fort Collins, Eaton said. Due to his father's overseas
work, Matthew Shepard traveled extensively during his school years,
studying at boarding schools in Switzerland and elsewhere in Europe.
During the past several years, he lived in Denver, where he worked as a
waiter and retail clerk. He moved to Laramie last spring to enter
college as a freshman, his aunt and uncle said. He had wanted to attend
the University of Wyoming because it was his father's alma mater, they
said.
* He enjoyed spirited political debate and wanted to work as a
human-rights advocate on behalf of the impoverished and downtrodden,
friends said.
* Friends say the attack on Shepard shows the need to pass hate crimes
legislation in Wyoming. Efforts to pass hate-crime legislation in
Wyoming have failed repeatedly because critics have said it would give
homosexuals special rights, said Marv Johnson, executive director of the
American Civil Liberties Union in Wyoming.
Fri Oct 9, 1998 - 6:38AM EDT -
ASSOCIATED PRESS BREAKS SHEPARD STORY NATIONALLY
Within one day of militant fumdamentalists holding a press conference in
Washington, DC promoting the "ex-gay" agenda, the Associated
Press reported that a gay student at the University of Wyoming was
savagely beaten, burned and left to die, tied to a wooden fence outside
Laramie Wyoming, 30 miles northwest of Cheyenne. Passersby
discovered the bloody and unconscious body of Matthew Shepard, a
22-year-old political science major, a mile northeast of Laramie on
Wednesday evening. His skull had been smashed with a blunt object.
Shepard was in critical condition and on a respirator at Poudre Valley
Hospital in Fort Collins. He was last heard from Tuesday evening
when he called friends from a bar.
Three University of Wyoming
students were arrested Thursday in connection with the beating and were
scheduled to be in court today. Shepard's body was found by two
motorcyclists who at first thought he was a scarecrow because of the way
he was positioned on the fence. Police were investigating whether
the brutal beating was motivated by Shepard's sexual orientation. He had
twice been beaten recently and attributed those attacks to his open
homosexuality, friends said.
Thu Oct 8, 1998 - FOCUS ON THE
FAMILY RE: 'NATIONAL COMING OUT OF HOMOSEXUALITY DAY'
"COLORADO SPRINGS, Colo., Oct. 8 /PRNewswire/ -- Focus on the Family
staffer and former homosexual, John Paulk, will mark `National Coming Out
of Homosexuality Day' by participating in a press conference this morning
at the National Press Club. Mr. Paulk works as a Homosexuality and
Gender Analyst for Focus on the Family and serves, along with his wife,
Anne, as a national spokesperson for the ex-gay movement.
"It's an honor to be a role
model for those struggling to leave homosexuality behind," says Paulk.
"My wife and I, and thousands of others, serve as living proof that
change is possible. By taking a bold stand against the lies that say
homosexuality is biological and unchangeable, we hope to encourage others
desperate to escape homosexuality.
"The gay activist agenda,
which includes `National Coming Out Day,' is promoted heavily by Hollywood
and the media. Focus on the Family believes that `National Coming
Out of Homosexuality Day' is crucial in order to provide the American
public with the other side of the issue.
"Primarily, our concern
centers on the destructive messages being sent to today's youth.
Millions of young people struggling with a variety of issues are being
encouraged to `come out' as a solution to their problems. Our goal
is to point teens, their parents and teachers in another direction -- that
of an achievable, healthy, normal heterosexual identity," says Paulk.
Focus on the Family is committed
to helping families sort through the facts and fiction surrounding youth
and homosexuality. Beginning next month, Focus will host conferences
nationwide that will address the promotion of homosexuality within the
public school setting.
"We believe that a young
person struggling with homosexual tendencies should also be informed of
healthy alternatives to homosexuality," says Paulk. "It is
irresponsible for educators to steer that person into a potentially
dangerous and lonely lifestyle. Through our conferences, we hope to
equip and educate all those concerned about the influence of homosexuality
on kids."
John and Anne Paulk recently
participated in a national ad campaign featuring ex-gays. The
firestorm that ensued landed the couple on the cover of Newsweek magazine,
as well as in stories run on ABC World News Tonight, U.S. News and
World Report, Time, Los Angeles Times, USA TODAY, and many others.
Check out Focus on the Family's
new college website at www.boundless.org. Articles this week explore
`National Coming Out of Homosexuality Day.'"
Wed Oct 7, 1998
-FUNDAMENTALISTS ANOUNCE "EX-GAY" PRESS CONFERENCE
"The CENTER FOR RECLAIMING AMERICA offers further hope for change to
those struggling in the homosexual lifestyle as it unveils the next phase
of its "Truth In Love" campaign at its press conference at 9:30
a.m., Thursday, October 8, 1998 at the National Press Club in Washington,
D.C.
With the release of two
television commercials produced by the CENTER, the campaign has expanded
its outreach, which began with full-page ads in major newspapers
nationwide (including The New York Times, USA TODAY, the Washington Post,
and The Wall Street Journal). Eighteen major pro-family organizations
joined together to respond to the hostility and name-calling aimed at
Senator Trent Lott and football player Reggie White, and others, when they
simply stated the biblical position that homosexuality is a sin.
The TV spots are designed to
address the homosexual issue honestly and lovingly. One of the 60-second
formats will feature several former homosexuals who are now happily
married and enjoying new lives with their children. Tom Cole, a former
homosexual, said, "The dream that I thought I could never have -- a
wife and children -- has come true." The ad clearly demonstrates that
many have left the lifestyle; in fact, thousands have done so.
Another commercial is designed to
appeal to the parents of those struggling in homosexuality. One mother,
Frances Johnston, who never stopped loving her son, said, "Just
because you love your children, doesn't mean you love everything they
do." She refused to embrace a lifestyle that she understood to be
immoral and destructive. Her son, Michael Johnston, appears with her in
the commercial, thanking her for her persevering love and her unyielding
principles.
Janet Folger, national director
for the CENTER FOR RECLAIMING AMERICA, said, "Each of these ads will
emphasize the Christian approach of offering compassionate love without
compromising the truth." Dr. D. James Kennedy, Senior Minister at
Coral Ridge Presbyterian Church, and founder of the CENTER, said,
"It's not about hate; it's about hope." This tag line appears
prominently in each of the ads.
In addition, Michael Johnston,
founder and president of Kerusso Ministries, will participate in the press
conference, to discuss the National Coming Out of Homosexuality Day,
October 11. Mr. Johnston began this event four years ago to encourage
those struggling in the lifestyle to seek the deliverance that is possible
through the power of Jesus Christ.
Other representatives from the
pro-family groups that comprise the "Truth In Love" campaign
will also be in attendance.
For more information and
interviews, call Carol Krpata, 954-351-3353, ext. 622.
The CENTER FOR RECLAIMING
AMERICA, formed by Dr. D. James Kennedy, is an outreach of Coral Ridge
Ministries to inform the American public and motivate people of faith to
defend and implement the biblical principles on which our country was
founded. With members in 50 states, the CENTER provides non-
partisan, interdenominational information, training, and support to all
those interested in impacting the culture and renewing the vision set
forth by our Founding Fathers."
Mon Oct 5, 1998 - RELIGIOUS
FUNDAMENTALISTS ANNOUNCE ANTI-GAY CELEBRATION
"Group Announces Fourth Annual 'National Coming Out Of Homosexuality
Day'
Homosexuals Encouraged to 'Come Out' of Homosexuality
NEWPORT NEWS, Va., Oct. 5 /PRNewswire/
-- Kerusso Ministries today announced the fourth annual National Coming
Out of Homosexuality Day (NCOHD) on October 11. The annual event is a
direct counter to the pro-homosexual message of organizations like the
National Gay and Lesbian Task Force, Human Rights Campaign and P-FLAG.
Michael Johnston, national chair of the event and a former homosexual with
AIDS said Monday, "The message from homosexual lobby groups is one of
anger and despair. They consistently blame everyone else for their misery
and offer no hope to the adult or young person struggling with homosexual
desires. All they can say is 'give up and give in'. The NCOHD
project offers a different message, a message of compassion and hope.
"There are thousands of men,
women and young people who have rejected a homosexual identity and gone on
to live healthy normal lives," Johnston said. He readily acknowledges
that the walk out of homosexuality can be a difficult one.
"These individuals desperately need to know that they are not alone
and that many are willing to guide and encourage them."
Johnston walked away from homosexuality in 1988 after living for eleven
years as an active homosexual. Johnston said, "It is
unfortunate that homosexual lobby groups continue to deny and even work to
suppress the truth about so many who have walked away from homosexuality.
It is cruel and anything but compassionate. They have convinced many,
including many in the media, to believe a lie. This week we will take the
truth to the streets to help the hurting. We will do it one community at a
time, one heart at a time; that they may know the truth and the truth will
set them free."
Events surrounding the October 11
observance of the National Coming Out of Homosexuality Day will span the
country from coast to coast. Activities will include educational and
ministerial outreach in local communities, churches and on college
campuses. Radio specials highlighting the stories of former homosexuals
are scheduled for hundreds of radio stations across the country as well as
television broadcasts in many markets.
National Sponsors include:
American Family Association, Americans for Truth About Homosexuality,
Christian Action League of North Carolina, Christian Coalition of Alaska,
Christian Coalition of Colorado, Christian Coalition of Washington,
Christian Family Network, Citizens for Community Values, Colorado for
Family Values, Concerned Women for America, Coral Ridge Ministries/Center
for Reclaiming America, CrossOver Ministries, Exodus International (North
America), Family Defense Council, Family Research Council, Family First,
Family Watch, Inc., Focus on the Family, Foundation for Christian
Alternatives, Freedom At Last, Institute for Media Education, Liberty
Counsel, Living Hope, Love of God Outreach, Metanoia Ministries, Mission
America, Mothers for Good Government, New Creation Ministries
(California), New Creation Ministries (Hawaii), New Hope Ministries,
Outpost, Regeneration, Renew America, Stop Promoting Homosexuality
America, The National Legal Foundation, Transforming Congregations,
Washington for Traditional Values and Washington Opposed to Pro-Homosexual
Policies."
Return to Home Page
|